Carson Palmer = Yes Please

[RockyTopVol]

I believe 100% that Clausen is not ready right now, but I'm not 100% sure that he'll always suck. A guy like this could be a good mentor for Jimmy. I'd be perfectly okay with this. Too bad we won't be able to make it happen until the CBA.

[Happy Panther]

He threw for 4,000 yards last season....an immediately and significant upgrade over anything we have or anything that we could bet in the draft or FA.

83 rating too.

His stats were the same if not slightly better than 2009 when they were in the playoffs.

[Darth Biscuit]

I've thought for a while now that Palmer would be a great fit here... still do.

[DaCityKats]

he would be an upgrade,but for how long. some games last year he looked straight up bad.swaping 1st for him would be an even dumber move than the 2nd for armanti. both would mean that we were screwed.

[CatMan72]

Its funny you say all that when the qb u want so bad is a has been wco qb. I would take Palmer over mcnabb here any day of the week.

Just because McNabb played in a WCO doesn't mean that's the only thing he's capable of... he throws a really nice deep ball.

Personally I'd take the QB who is still physically capable of performing his job (McNabb)

[csx]

Just because McNabb played in a WCO doesn't mean that's the only thing he's capable of... he throws a really nice deep ball.

Personally I'd take the QB who is still physically capable of performing his job (McNabb)

McNabb is infamous with Eagles fans for underthrowing receivers.

[MadHatter]

Just because McNabb played in a WCO doesn't mean that's the only thing he's capable of... he throws a really nice deep ball.

Personally I'd take the QB who is still physically capable of performing his job (McNabb)

Did you watch ANY Washington games? McNabb was terrible last season. He fuging got benched TWICE in the same season.

[teeray]

Tired of reading most of you say Palmer is not needed here.

News Flash: He would instantly be the best QB the Panthers have ever had.

6'5, 236lbs , he fits the physical mold that Rivera has stated he wants.

31 years old, 9 years experience. He has 4-5 good years left in him. He would not be a "stop gap"

First overall pick in 2003. Guess what, he wasn't a bust unlike the majority of QB's in this years draft inevitably will be.

Career QB rating of 86.9. Palmer was 6th in the league in passing in 2010 EVEN THOUGH the Bengals averaged a league low 3.6 yards per carry on the ground. Think teams were game planning against the run? Think again.

In short, shut your pie holes, we would be fortunate to get Palmer.

At what price. If it is going to take two #1 draft picks than no.

I would love to have him but is he good enough to give the farm away is my only thing!

[CatMan72]

He threw for 4,000 yards last season....an immediately and significant upgrade over anything we have or anything that we could bet in the draft or FA.

Saying he's a significant upgrade over anything we have isn't saying much, LOL

All things being equal, I'd much rather get McNabb... there's clearly something wrong with Palmer's arm.

[MadHatter]

Whether our up and coming QB next season is Clausen, Cam, or Gabbert....it is VERY clear that we must have a vet starter. And, Palmer is better than any other option in FA or that would be available in a trade (for a decent price).

[teeray]

Whether our up and coming QB next season is Clausen, Cam, or Gabbert....it is VERY clear that we must have a vet starter. And, Palmer is better than any other option in FA or that would be available in a trade (for a decent price).

Despite your mean comment to me on another thread ; I agree :grouphug::grouphug:

:D:D

[CatMan72]

Did you watch ANY Washington games? McNabb was terrible last season. He fuging got benched TWICE in the same season.

I did, the Skins are a crappy team and any QB who goes there is doomed to fail.

You think we have a bad offensive line and a crappy receiving corp? ...take a look at the Skins. Most of the Skins o-line starters wouldn't even make it as backups on other teams. I watched enough of the Skins to know that McNabb had no time to throw the ball and was running for his life, because nobody was open.

[Happy Panther]

McNabb is infamous with Eagles fans for underthrowing receivers.

Eagles fans could probably overlook that due to the high yards TDS and rating and low interceptions he compiled for 11 years.

I get the feeling if were were pursuing Joe Montana in his prime people would complain about his throwing motion

[mmmbeans]

eagles fans could probably overlook that due to the high yards tds and rating and low interceptions he compiled for 11 years.

I get the feeling if were were pursuing joe montana in his prime people would complain about his throwing motion

he's shorter than teh claussen!