JaMarcus Russell and Alex Smith killed it at their combines...

[YourMomsLover]

Everyone is bored and starved for anything new.

I dont know how to respond to this without pissing someone off. (Not you MG)

Screw it Ill do it...we needs a QB, cause Jimmy Jam isnt dat deal. But this QB draft class is soo freakin lame and mediocre, that Im prepared for another season of losing. IMO

[Mr. Scot]

I dont know how to respond to this without pissing someone off. (Not you MG)

Screw it Ill do it...we needs a QB, cause Jimmy Jam isnt dat deal. But this QB draft class is soo freakin lame and mediocre, that Im prepared for another season of losing. IMO

I'm not convinced that we have to have a losing season next year (though given the transition, it wouldn't surprise me that much) but regardless, I'd rather spend a season with a veteran stopgap and/or get some definitive info on Clausen than reach for a guy at #1 when there's clearly no QB worth that pick.

[Jangler]

Gosh, I hope he doesn't have a bad rookie season....

[KillerKat]

Said before I don't care for the combine and hate how so much stock is put into it. The guys have game film on them. That should be all that is needed.

[Sam Mills Fan]

Hey Scotty, you're now saying the combine is very important? That's not what you were saying earlier this month:

http://www.carolinahuddle.com/forum/showpost.php?p=2949438&postcount=17

"Won't matter to us, though. Rivera has made clear that game tape weighs much more heavily in his mind than workout numbers."

http://www.carolinahuddle.com/forum/showpost.php?p=2947293&postcount=36

"(The combine and pro days) should never have a big influence on those grades though. Any team who moves a guy up a round in their estimation based on workouts is asking for the next Mike Mamula."

http://www.carolinahuddle.com/forum/showpost.php?p=2904037&postcount=31

"The Panthers scouting philosophy emphasizes game performance, so I honestly wouldn't expect the Combine to change anything."

[Dpantherman]

here we go again

[Jangler]

I believe Mr Scot is saying you are saying the combine means nothing since the great hype didn't. or did, IDK who gives a poo.

[monstercat]

Again, the NFL Network team, including Mayock, all said that Cam looked better in games than he did throwing against air today.

[KillerKat]

Again, the NFL Network team, including Mayock, all said that Cam looked better in games than he did throwing against air today.

You shut your ***** mouth. Don't make Highlandfire cry.

[SorthNarolina]

Predictable. Not addressing the content of the post at all. :rolleyes:

The content of the post is that the combine is more icing on the cake than anything, which pretty much everybody knows.

[Sam Mills Fan]

I believe Mr Scot is saying you are saying the combine means nothing since the great hype didn't. or did, IDK who gives a poo.

I've said in the past that the combine is important I think, but that was until I sat down within the past hour to actually research just how important it is.

[YourMomsLover]

I'm not convinced that we have to have a losing season next year (though given the transition, it wouldn't surprise me that much) but regardless, I'd rather spend a season with a veteran stopgap and/or get some definitive info on Clausen than reach for a guy at #1 when there's clearly no QB worth that pick.

Im going back on what I have said. But Jimmy wasnt good last year, and I hope he can (maybe) prove us wrong this year like P Manning did. I honestly dont see it happening though. But I have hope!

[Swarly]

Funny. Up to now I saw a lot of people talking about how important the combine was. Now suddenly it isn't.

Wonder why :rolleyes:

lol this

Everybody(including me) thought Newton would be phenomenal today. He wasn't, so now all of a sudden it's worthless.

With that said, I actually do think it's not that important. Game tape is the most important thing. My biggest issue with Cam was everyone was saying how he improved his game/etc, but I really saw no major improvements with his throwing today.

[YourMomsLover]

lol this

Everybody(including me) thought Newton would be phenomenal today. He wasn't, so now all of a sudden it's worthless.

With that said, I actually do think it's not that important. Game tape is the most important thing. My biggest issue with Cam was everyone was saying how he improved his game/etc, but I really saw no major improvements with his throwing today.

and neither did I.