Smitty to pats?

[OneBadassCat]

Smith would be an absolute monster in NE.

[rayzor]

smitty for a 2nd would be a steal.

if we managed to pull that off i would turn right around and trade that 2nd for a WR that really is worth a 2nd rounder.

only way we trade smith away is if the end result is us getting an upgrade at WR.

[B.BERSIN]

Go ahead and trade him,I love him but I love Panthers more,what's more,he will be more productive in NE

[rayzor]

meh...i don't care what he or any other former panther does on any team. once a guy is gone, he's gone and not at all important unless he's on my fantasy team.

for all i care he could drop off the face of the planet quicker than joey galloway. i'm a fan if he's here, but if he's gone he's irrelevant.

[Bj-Monster23]

no chance Smitty gets us a 2nd rounder. this isn't Madden, we'd be VERY lucky to get a 3rd rounder. realistically we'd get a 4th rounder.

with that said, the thought of Brady to Smith scares me. we'd basically be trading them a trip to the super bowl.

I still think we should keep him though, unless he starts openly demanding a trade. The return just isn't worth it.

Do it matter its not like they will be facing us in the superbowl..

[B.BERSIN]

meh...i don't care what he or any other former panther does on any team. Once a guy is gone, he's gone and not at all important unless he's on my fantasy team.

For all i care he could drop off the face of the planet quicker than joey galloway. I'm a fan if he's here, but if he's gone he's irrelevant.

right

[Shermdog]

ahahah, i didnt think of it that way. At least these fools didnt trade this no 1 pick for jimmy clausen last year, they tried their best

That makes me sick just thinking about it.........Thank God Hurney didn't get that done.

[MadHatter]

So practically trade Steve Smith for Armanti Edwards? BRILLIANT!

Not

The Amrnati Edwards pick is a moot point...a sunk cost if you may.

You have to look at a possible Smith for a 2nd round pick separately. I love Smith's fire and playmaking ability. However, getting a 2nd round pick for an aging WR would be great compensation....not to mention that with the youth movement we are in, it is no given that Smitty woudl re-sign after 2012.

Depending on whether he is set on being dealt, the top 2nd round pick would be a steal for us.

[Doc Holiday]

No one ever wins in trades that involve the Patriots unless of course you are the Patriots, why anyone still trades with them after time and again the same results is beyond me

[ECUPantherFan]

We already had our a$$ handed to us by New England when we traded that pick for Edwards. Stupid decision. Now, we're going to get screwed again with the same pick. Awesome. Way to go front office.

[OchoNueve]

How about we just keep him... I can name 30 other teams I would rather he go to than the Pats.

[j2sgam]

[csx]

How about we just keep him... I can name 30 other teams I would rather he go to than the Pats.

The issuue would be can he?

[riddel]

Hurney's ineptitude made concrete. Let's trade smith for Edwards! yay!

tru dat.