Peepers or Jenkies

[Panthro]

Who would you rather have starting on the Panthers. One caveat...both are happy to be playing here.

[panther4life]

jenkins

[Kyle82]

Of course Pep

[Panthro]

See if both were happy to be here I would take Jenkins 8 out of 10 days...I like pressure up the middle (Thats what she said)

[Mr. Scot]

Given the choice of both with a desire to play here, Jenkins. Partially because interior pressure can be more disruptive, but also because of the perception that Jenkins played harder on the field than Peppers did.

[megadeth078]

Jenkins

No doubt about it. Peppers and his one good play every other game isn't worth it.

[Highlandfire]

Jenkins

[Snake]

Thats an easy one. Jenk cause as talented as Jpep is he still dose not have the nasty nature that Jenk possessed and punished QBs with.

[hmsmike]

Jenkins

[rayzor]

Jenkins

No doubt about it. Peppers and his one good play every other game isn't worth it.

what if both had nonstop motors?

[5158Poundin]

easy...the Big Kid.

Nothing more disruptive when he had his game on.

[PowerlessDan]

Peppers, he doesn't miss games.

[I am Hubby]

The wife says that a frontal assault is more effective, because you see it coming. You get nervous and want to get the hell outta there. Whereas, sneaking in from around the back isn't scary because you don't see it coming.

So using her logic, I would take Jenkins. QBs see him coming and can be forced into making mistakes.

Jenkins is a mistake maker, where Pep is a sack taker. I would go with the mistake maker every time.

[The Link]

Pepper's.

If he truly wanted to be here, he would make plays every game.

Not to mention he isn't a locker room cancer.