Carson Palmer scenarios

[Nicbsbll2]

28 people out of 44 are saying stick with Jimmy?

/headdesk

If he showed ANYTHING at all this season, I'd agree. But he's not NFL starter stock people! FFS....

The only reason people are choosing to stick with Pickles is because the other options are just that bad.

[Seamonk]

You guys are wanting to give up so much for Palmer.. It only took a 3rd and a 5th to ship Jenkins.. Wanting a disgruntled player like Boldin, Jenkins, Moss has its advantages..

[CRA]

The only reason people are choosing to stick with Pickles is because the other options are just that bad.

how is Palmer just as bad as sticking w/ Clausen?

[blackcatgrowl]

how is Palmer just as bad as sticking w/ Clausen?

I was wondering the same thing.

[TheRealDeal]

how is Palmer just as bad as sticking w/ Clausen?

Probably due to the amount of compensation we'd give to the Bengals for Palmer in the choices for the poll.

[Mr. Scot]

GM Mike Brown says he won't be traded, as of this morning.

Also as of this morning, NFL experts say Mike Brown is still one of the dumbest owners in all of sports.

[Nicbsbll2]

how is Palmer just as bad as sticking w/ Clausen?

I'm not saying that Palmer=Clausen, because we all know that Palmer brings a lot to the table that Clausen doesn't (ie. experience, leadership, etc). But given Palmers age, contract and recent performance history, we would be better off just sticking with Clausen then giving up any of the above trade scenarios for Palmer.

If we could get Palmer for say a 6th rounder or so, then I say go for it. Any more compensation than that is too much imo.

[CRA]

I'm not saying that Palmer=Clausen, because we all know that Palmer brings a lot to the table that Clausen doesn't (ie. experience, leadership, etc). But given Palmers age, contract and recent performance history, we would be better off just sticking with Clausen then giving up any of the above trade scenarios for Palmer.

If we could get Palmer for say a 6th rounder or so, then I say go for it. Any more compensation than that is too much imo.

well, he isn't worth his current deal. If Carolina can rework a new deal w/ him.....he would 100% be worth it if he was obtained by reasonable means. Palmer could start. If Rivera brings in more than just one body to compete.....I have a hard time believing Jimmy could beat anyone other than Pike.

[SOJA]

wow are you serious?

Option number two:

[SOJA]

Options two and three are completely asinine, Daniel Snyder is that you?

[MattB]

Not sure why he would want to come here considering he's sick of losing with the Bengals. Plus he's making 12m next year.

[chknwing]

Palmer wont be coming here. Carolina wants a young qb to grow with their young receiver corp. They dont want to have to replace qbs, every couple of years. They want a dynasty, to compete in the playoffs year after year.

[CRA]

Palmer wont be coming here. Carolina wants a young qb to grow with their young receiver corp. They dont want to have to replace qbs, every couple of years. They want a dynasty, to compete in the playoffs year after year.

well, if they stick w/ Clausen this year.....they likely have to replace him the next year. Then they are going to be forced to draft a kid and start him......and there may not be a kid that can handle that.

at this point, they can rule out the Kurt Warner/Delhomme/etc. search either. Older guys that can come in and lead.

[brandon_87]

Clausen and a 4th plus they give us a 5th or 6th and it sounds good, but I wonder if they would take Pike and a 4th?

Just don't get your hopes up though, he wants to play on the west coast and my guess is seattle to be back with carroll or san francisco because they have a worse qb situation then us and would do anything to get a qb of that caliber and not have to use a 1st round pick on one