American Idol

[Dpantherman]

I thought that was Stefano's best to date

[rodeo]

haha Paul is so awesome.

[sunbunny]

Shut up, Rodeo, before I go kick your ass. LOL I vote for James, Scotty, and Paul.

I vote for everyone except Pia and Casey, ummm Stefano, Jacob.

[Dpantherman]

damn, no one really stood out as being really bad. But I think Stefano will be the odd man out

[rodeo]

Can I ask you guys honestly why everyone overlooks that James can't sing for poo?

[The Graduate]

Don't get your hopes up. There won't be a girl in the final 3, maybe not the final 5. Women haven't done well on the show in years and there probably won't be another female winner for several seasons. The voting base are teenage girls and old white ladies who vote for boys.

Carrie Underwood would be the exception to most of the female winners.

Remember Chris Daughtry. He got voted out and has had pretty good career.

It will be interesting to see how Casey with the stand up bass does after this is over. Or how popular the stand up bass becomes. It's just so different it may carry him after this is over regardless of how he does. Time will tell.

[The Graduate]

damn, no one really stood out as being really bad. But I think Stefano will be the odd man out

I just finished saying the same thing to the wife. Stefano put on a good performance of the song, While my Guitar.... Pretty tough song to do considering Eric Clapton was playing on the original along with Lennon.

This was only one night and James doesn't impress me much either.

[Seal (SmittyIsOurSavior)]

I can't stand up for Stefano this week. He's going home. It's my least favorite Stefano performance since Top 13.

[Darth Urious]

Stefano is gone...

James took a bad risk, and he is starting to crack, I think...

Casey is now my #1 again...

Haley is still in my good graces, but she is getting more annoying... like rodeo said, judges fault...

Pia and Lauren are still battling for best girl... Pia currently has it, but if Lauren ever gets her damn confidence she'll blow her away...

Jacob was good as usual...

Paul was very good to me tonight... I loved it...

Scotty is just so fuging corny now it isn't funny... It is like watching Woody from Toy Story up there moving around... loved the "It's Bo-Time" shirt in the warmup footage though, lol...

[g5jamz]

Easy night...great singing...Stefano goes home. He's just too weak of a singer.

[Hawk]

good write up Darth...I agree alot. Casey kicked it...I absolutely love Pia...she's gorgeous and she can sing!!

Stefano goes I think

[Seal (SmittyIsOurSavior)]

Haley is still my favorite girl. Pia has nice tatas though.

[Mr. Scot]

damn, no one really stood out as being really bad. But I think Stefano will be the odd man out

I'd agree, but you never know with these things.

[Zaximus]

I think Paul did very well, he hit some notes I haven't heard him hit before, he has some more to show us we haven't seen. I do wish Paul was the one singing the CCR song, I swear he could sing CCR well.

I actually thought Stefano did decent, and I usually don't.

I think everyone did great. One of the most solid nights. Honestly, this season is one of the better ones in a long time, lots of different singers.

I liked James this week, it wasn't perfect, but you don't always have to hit things perfect on a song like that, he did well.

Jacob is still the best singer on here.

Going home? Probably either Stefano or Haley I think.