American Idol

[Darth Urious]

I was kinda right again... Naima switched out with Stefano...

Stefano and Paul have to be next, though... followed by Haley...

The sucky thing is that Lauren or Pia could get booted way too soon in favor of someone like Scotty if they have an off night, even though they are way better than most of them...

[Seal (SmittyIsOurSavior)]

Lauren and Pia will be the Final Two. It's theirs to lose.

I'm glad Stefano stayed. You guys give Pia all the credit in the world, but in reality, Stefano is the male version of Pia, except he moves around more and puts more heart, soul, and emotion into his stuff.

[rodeo]

He puts fake emotion into it. Sings all pained but doesn't connect with the song at all.

[Seal (SmittyIsOurSavior)]

He puts fake emotion into it. Sings all pained but doesn't connect with the song at all.

I completely disagree. I keep referring back to his performance where he was saved, but you can tell he meant what he was saying. I agree that he lacks audience connection, but he puts tons of emotion into it.

[rodeo]

Yes he puts emotion into it. The same kind Beiber puts into it when he's so passionate about the lyrics "baby baby baby ooo." He performs the emotion but there's nothing real there.

[sunbunny]

I still think Pia and Stefano are boring. I wouldn't pay to see them in concert. I'd pay to see James, Paul (as long he danced/had fits), Haley, and maybe Scottie if I got drunk enough to listen to country music.

I'm still on the fence about Casey. He needs to sing Mustang Sally.

[Darth Urious]

I completely disagree. I keep referring back to his performance where he was saved, but you can tell he meant what he was saying. I agree that he lacks audience connection, but he puts tons of emotion into it.

When was Stefano saved? Casey got the only save of the season...

[sunbunny]

Maybe when Stefano got the wild card?

[Darth Urious]

Maybe when Stefano got the wild card?

ah okay

[Dpantherman]

Jacob 'popped' it up this week. He probably could have blown 'Lets Get it On' , but he did a damn good job with 'Man in the Mirror'. Nice seeing him sing something more pop....even if its Rock N Roll week

[Mr. Scot]

That time again.

Jacob fantastic as always.

I have a feeling Haley singing Janis Joplin will be a scream-fest :(

[Dpantherman]

But since MJ is in the Rock N Roll HOF it works I guess.

[Dpantherman]

Haley can sing, but Janis Joplin song or not, I don't like the growling

[rodeo]

But the judges make her growl. She started off not doing it and they kept telling her to.

That was a pretty good performance.