American Idol

[g5jamz]

Jacob was all over the place last night I feel.

Top 3:

Pia

Scotty

Stefano

Bottom 3:

Naima

Karen

Hailey

Naima or Karen should go home.

[Darth Urious]

Karen, Haley, and Stefano are my bottom 3... Naima could replace Stefano though for all I care...

Karen should go home... We get it... you are Hispanic... stop changing song lyrics because of it...

Casey picked the wrong song, and yes "mosquito" is in there, although he did say a couple other lines slightly wrong... He's picking songs that will be fun for him, and can get away with it... He better be careful it doesn't catch up with him though...

Jacob is the best singer by a mile...

James is probably picking the most correct songs of the bunch...

Lauren redeemed herself, sick or not...

Thia continues to sing a lot older than she is, and should have probably waited a couple years to be put through to Hollywood... She should outlast several more of them though...

Paul is just getting boring/old fast...

Pia is the best girl by far, and could likely record an album now... She has the range of Mariah and Christina...

Stefano is just meh to me... all his songs sound the same, and his pitch is just weird and not really dynamic...

Scotty was Scotty... boring, and he's toast as soon as he can't sing a country song...

Karen sucked and is average at best... Haley is cocky as hell, and not as good as she thinks she is... Naima is better than both of them, but I'm not really feeling her song choices...

[Kyle82]

Jacob Lusk is the next American Idol :cool:

[Darth Urious]

I think the top 3 will be:

James

Jacob

and depending on what songs he chooses, Casey... and if he picks bad ones, Pia...

I could see any of those 4 winning it all depending on what songs they pick and how hard they try...

[Hawk]

this show did nothing for me really...nothing really outstanding in my opinion.

Pia...still love her and damn that girl has some pipes. In her defense, the judges are trying to get her to venture out of her comfort zone and I still think she brought it.

Casey...that was just weird for me...if it was the first time I seen him, I'd dislike him, but I like that he took a chance. I'm sure he's done enough in the last few weeks to be safe.

James is certainly having alot of fun. Kid can sing and entertain, maybe just needs to remember he's not a star just yet, but confidence is a good thing!

Scotty...obviously could take any country song and sing the poo out of it. Interesting that they aren't asking him to venture into something different...like it was said, he's dancing with the girl that brought him, no doubt there.

Stephano did well tonight I think...his strongest.

and Lusk...the guy can sing, no doubt there, I'm just wondering if more people will start to get annoyed with his over singing maybe? Just doesn't work for me as much as some.

Paul...he just needs to go home I think. Initially thought his voice was interesting and different...now its moving over to plain annoying.

The rest...I just see the seperation starting to grow between what I think are the top few....Pia, Scotty, James, Casey and Lusk...and the rest of them...with two kind of on the bubble in between...Stephano and the country chick with the big ass!...the rest...one by one...the are leaving

[Dpantherman]

You can already see the divide in the competition as far as talent is concerned. Usually comes down to song choice.

[g5jamz]

Lusk would have been awesome last night if he'd just held the notes strong without so much vibratto. It's almost distracting to the song. Yes...you can do it...but overdoing it makes the tempo yucky.

[Dpantherman]

agreed. He has the Jennifer Hudson problem. She did the exact same thing when she was on, I still to this day think she is a better singer than Fantasia.

[Zaximus]

Yeah it wasn't a great night overall really, maybe cause they had less options on song choice, not sure. I like Tyler and Aerosmith but I find it kind of funny when he tells James to "not go too poppy on me" when that is exactly what Aerosmith did when the 90's came around (although it did rejuvenate the band though).

[Anybodyhome]

Yeah it wasn't a great night overall really, maybe cause they had less options on song choice, not sure. I like Tyler and Aerosmith but I find it kind of funny when he tells James to "not go too poppy on me" when that is exactly what Aerosmith did when the 90's came around (although it did rejuvenate the band though).

Maybe he meant opium poppy? And why is this show still on when it obviously jumped the shark a couple years ago.

Seriously, I heard they're allowing kids on?

[Dpantherman]

Forgot about idol tonight :lol: who went home?

[Darth Urious]

Forgot about idol tonight :lol: who went home?

Karen

Bottom 3 was her, Haley, and Naima...

[Dpantherman]

im impressed. they got it right

[rodeo]

Was thrilled she went home. Why anyone would vote for her is beyond me when you have Pia singing the same style of music 20 times better.

Haley is very underrated, I hope she sings something good next week.