American Idol

[Dpantherman]

I like that each contestant has a producer to work with, BUT some of these song will jump the shark. I worry about "Whats Love to Do with it" the remix...

[Dpantherman]

Naima, I don't think that song needed that big of a remix. id give it a 4/10

[Dpantherman]

Chris - "I guess thats why they call it the blues"

I really don't like his voice, his voice sounds like matchbox 20 1997 (ive said this before)

[Dpantherman]

5/10

[Dpantherman]

Thia singing Whitney houston?

[Dpantherman]

I dont think that was Whitney Houston...boring 6/10

edit: that was actually that Pocahontas song

[Mr. Scot]

I really don't like his voice, his voice sounds like matchbox 20 1997 (ive said this before)

Guessing you mean Paul.

The image I get listening to him is Rod Stewart at age twelve, when his voice was changing.

First two performances weren't so good.

[Dpantherman]

I think his name is Chris

[Mr. Scot]

I dont think that was Whitney Houston...boring 6/10

Vanessa Williams, and I never liked that song.

I like her, but I agree with what they said about her needing to do some different things.

Jennifer Lopez is rough tonight.

[Dpantherman]

yea she is being tougher than normal tonight

[Mr. Scot]

Sad to know I graduated high school before some of these kids were even born :(

I was kinda hoping James would do some old Van Halen, but Bon Jovi could work.

[Dpantherman]

I just can't get into James Durbin.

[Mr. Scot]

I hate that song, but I think James is the best of the bunch.

Cracked up at his comments to Tyler :lol:

[Dpantherman]

first bleep of the season by Steven, won't be the last