American Idol

[Mr. Scot]

I'd actually give the "marketability" edge to James (except in the "horny guys" demographic).

[Zaximus]

Scotty will probably do better than all these guys in the industry, honestly. His voice is ready.

The Diana Ross girl is TERRIBLE and shouldn't even be this far in.

Jacob Lusk is so far ahead of anyone in terms of talent, but he won't win. He's pretty awesome.

Pia is boring, she's good but I think she's boring, been there and done that with those type of singers before.

[Dpantherman]

America got it right with the bottom 3

[Darth Urious]

Haley Reinhart, Ashton Jones, or Karen Rodriguez = gone tonight

Can I call it or what? ;)

[Hawk]

pretty sure I was 2/3....and happy with the choice!

[Seal (SmittyIsOurSavior)]

Haley Reinhart didn't deserve bottom 3. She's fantastic, she just had one bad night.

The chick who got kicked really sucked though.

[Mr. Scot]

It's reasonable to think the "wild card" people won't last long, barring phenomenal performances or shifts in public opinion.

Not always true mind you (Aiken was a wild card) but it's logical.

[sunbunny]

Did I miss anything other than Lambert performing? I already found the youtube of his performance, so I got my Glambert fix.

[Seal (SmittyIsOurSavior)]

Did I miss anything other than Lambert performing? I already found the youtube of his performance, so I got my Glambert fix.

P-Diddy and Skylar Grey performed, and it actually impressed me.

[Hawk]

I would have liked to see Lambert sing with James

[Mr. Scot]

Maybe a pairing of James and Judas Priest will be down the road.

Also would like a Lauren Alaina/Steven Tyler duet (Don't Wanna Miss A Thing).

[Razzy]

Jacob Lusk is by far the best. His range is incredible, once he learns to really control and use it he's going to be good. He really reminds me of some of the really good 50's and 60's singers. Bandstand, motown, big band, etc. That just isn't marketable though and that's what it's all about.

[Mr. Scot]

Anyone else glad the prize is with a different record company this season?

[Zaximus]

Haley in the bottom 3 is nuts. She's really great, and is hot. The women probably didn't vote for her though. The rest was pretty spot on. I'm glad she got voted off, she was terrible and boring, and shouldn't even have got another chance. The red headed guy would have been better, but didn't even get a chance to be a wildcard.