American Idol

[Darth Urious]

Paul McDonald is a spaz/weird as hell... but I think a couple girls will be gone before a guy is sent home... Stefano was unimpressive, also...

[Hawk]

Paul McDonald is a spaz/weird as hell... but I think a couple girls will be gone before a guy is sent home... Stefano was unimpressive, also...

Stefano pisses me off really...he's got a pretty decent voice but of all the songs to sing, he choose that? too many people will have no idea what he sang!!! Awesome to have Stevie Wonder as your Idol and all...but way better songs to pick! McDonald is a spazz and he's growing to annoy me. I'd like to pick a song or two for him to pick and then staple his ass to a chair...the dancing is a huge distraction for me!

[Mr. Scot]

Scotty is very arrogant/confident and the whole looking around and pointing etc...annoying!!!

See, to me that's just part of being a performer (stage presence).

no love for Casey? I like him...I liked the Jacob dude too...but he's gone a little over the top for me and I just didn't get the whole song last night...butchered it in my opinion.

Casey is entertaining, but kind of a "niche" guy for me. The others are better overall performers.

[Hawk]

agreed...guess it's just annoying...Scotty that is...but it fits his persona perfectly so can't argue there.

Casey just impresses me...he's having fun, I like his voice and personality. Top 5 for me.

[g5jamz]

I want McDonald to go home. I just think that was awful last night. He or Karen Rodriguez.

[Dpantherman]

To me, Paul = Taylor Hicks. There is some variance, but I feel its a fair comparison.

[Seal (SmittyIsOurSavior)]

I f*cking love Paul McDonald, but last night was pretty bad.

Pia impressed me, Casey did too as always. I love Haley Reinhart, but that whole country sh*t last night was not good at all.

[sunbunny]

Dialidol has the top 4 as:

1. Scotty McCreery with a HUGE lead over anyone else. 12.161

2. James Durbin 5.894

3. Jacob Lusk 5.893

4. Pia Tuscano 5.847

Bottom 4 are:

Haley

Ashthon

Casey

Paul

[Darth Urious]

Dialidol has the top 4 as:

1. Scotty McCreery with a HUGE lead over anyone else. 12.161

2. James Durbin 5.894

3. Jacob Lusk 5.893

4. Pia Tuscano 5.847

Bottom 4 are:

Haley

Ashthon

Casey

Paul

I think they are confusing Casey and Scotty... lol... If McCreery even makes top 4, I will never watch idol again...

[Hawk]

ya...you swap Scotty and Casey and that list would be pretty accurate for my opinion too

[Seal (SmittyIsOurSavior)]

McCreery will be HUGE in country music, I guarantee it. His voice is so ready for the big time.

I honestly think Pia is the most marketable of them all though. I could see her being a big mainstream artist, like Mariah Carey was in the 90's.

[sunbunny]

Even though I think she'll win it, Pia is boring. She's the same old, same old.

Even taking into consideration dialidols margin of error, Scotty still had a huge lead over everyone else last night. He won't be voted off any time soon. Anyone not in the top 4 could go home, according the moe.

Also, don't underestimate teenagers and family voting for Scotty. I'm sure they're all hooked up with the software, so they can vote hundreds of times per line. That's actually for any contestant, though. It's how VFTW kept in Sanjaya for so long.

[Hawk]

bunny...I've banned people for less!!!!

I sort of agree with you...not that she's boring, but that she does need to mix it up some. A different type of song to show off different strengths in her voice is needed. That said, when you are working in a single elimination event, it's a little scary to experiment too much.

[Kyle82]

Pia and Jacob Lusk are the true talents...but I can see the girl that sang the Leann Rymes song (Hannah?) and maybe the young oriental girl going home tonite.