American Idol

[Dpantherman]

Naima. I loved that. Donnie Hathaway was a great choice. Idk why pick awesome songs right when they are about to get booted. Pick a good song the first time!

[Mr. Scot]

Feel sorry for Brett.

To Clint and Jordan, a great big "Ha Ha" since they screwed people over in the Hollywood Round. They deserve what they're getting now :D

[Dpantherman]

i dont like this big-nosed guy

[Dpantherman]

I knew Naimi would make it!! that Donnie Hathaway song was brilliant. Very strong group this season. alot better than last season as a whole

[Mr. Scot]

I probably won't see any more of it live.

[sunbunny]

I liked Brett. Damn. Not the best singer, but he seems like a sweet kid.

My two faves made it; James and Scotty. I'm not really drawn to any of the girls.

[Mr. Scot]

Favorites: James, Scotty, Lauren, Haley, Jacob.

Ironic. I hate country music, but two of my favorites are country singers.

[Mr. Scot]

For those that haven't seen...

[Seal (SmittyIsOurSavior)]

I think Stefano's wild card song last night was the best performance of the season.

[Seal (SmittyIsOurSavior)]

This one.

[Darth Urious]

Sorry, but IMO there will be 3-4 girls gone before one guy is gone... Unless one of those guys is the Aladdin looking guy...

[g5jamz]

Can't disagree with the findings. Wish the colombian chick had made it through and admitted she didn't come at it strong enough. She seems to be one of those that require that instrument to bring out her best. It cost her.

Surprised they didn't ask her to sing.

That red-haired dude stank the other night IMO. I believe one of the wild cards, Karen Rodriguez, or the Rod Stewart sounding fella will fall next...unless they surprise everyone.

[Dpantherman]

BTW, that goodness they brought Nygel back as EP. Getting to the top 13 this quick makes the show flow better. and the talent as a whole is way better than last year.

[Zaximus]

The guys were pretty spot on except for not letting the red headed dude sing again. If he had a chance and sang Queen again, with a BAND, he's nail it.

The girls was kind of wrong IMO. The best girl of the night IMO was the "bigger" girl (she's not that big just saying) that sang the song about cleaning floors. She didn't even get to sing for wild card. Big mistake.

The "diva" girl sucks, and shouldn't have made it through on "attitude". That's stupid.

The worst part of the show was JLo's terrible video.