American Idol

[Dpantherman]

I wish these a**holes would pick a night. I was thinking it was Wednesdays and Thursdays

[Dpantherman]

I hate Country, but this Scotty guy from NC, sounded like a pro

[sunbunny]

Love Scotty, but James was awesome singing Judas Priest. Holy hell.

[Dpantherman]

Didn't tune in until 20 minutes til.

this Paul McDonald dude sucked imo, horrible dancing too

[Dpantherman]

HE IS KILLING Luther!! wow. reminds me of Johnny Gill

[Dpantherman]

Jacob Lusk. best rendition of Luther on idol to date.

[sunbunny]

OMG You need to find James singing JP tonight on youtube. He was fandamntastic.

[Dpantherman]

What the hell was that Casey Abrams

[Dpantherman]

wtf, the judges loved that poo?

[Dpantherman]

that james duded like an Adam Lambert clone to me

[sunbunny]

Disagree, and I love me some Adam.

LOL My daughter is over here bitching that she can't get through to vote for Scotty. I think all of this area is on the phone right now.

[Mr. Scot]

Scheduling screwed me too. Was able to find videos of the performances, but none that included the judges comments :(

Honestly, I thought at least half of them sucked, maybe more.

Liked Casey and Scotty. Jacob was very good. Star of the night was easily James though. He hit some notes most guys couldn't hit without damaging themselves.

Recap said there was a sign in the audience that said "Tourettes Rocks". They pointed out it would have been better to say "Tourettes (bleeping) Rocks" :lol:

[Mr. Scot]

And how did this thread go this far without someone posting this?

Tyler from 1:25 on is hilarious to watch. So is Seacrest's reaction and the final wrap afterward :lol:

[Darth Urious]

I had no idea they were cutting 7 guys and 7 girls by next week... Who are the top 5 guys?

Scotty

Jacob

James

Casey

Paul

???

I thought they all did alright last night... Brett was my least favorite along with Jordan, who was horrible...