Is it an argument anymore????

[PanthersFanInGA]

Without Warner, Fitzgerald would be lost on that field. I have a feeling with Warner gone, we won't be hearing about #11 nearly as much.

[Cpt slay a ho]

my comparison......play a steve smith highlight reel,then play a fitz highlight reel......which one is more amazing....there you go.

smith is better for a number of reasons,but fitz anit far from smith

i mean really when smith has 3 rec for a 100 yds and td,while andre and fitz have 11 rec 100yds and a td.that should tell you something.....smith makes every catch count

[Baschski]

play a steve smith highlight reel,then play a fitz highlight reel......which one is more amazing....there you go.

Exactly! Finally someone gets what I'm saying.

[goodlay]

It's like comparing two HOF's, obviously one is better, but it's kind of pointless to decipher which one is better, because they are both great.

[Cpt slay a ho]

i like arguments like theses,it gives some of us fans a chance to show what we got nfl knowledge wise.

[X-Clown]

i like arguments like theses,it gives some of us fans a chance to show what we got nfl knowledge wise.

Or lack thereof

[Panthro]

This turned into a moron homeresque circle jerk

[JeramiahCopperfield]

Superman vs Spiderman.

Superman wins.

[CharlotteBeer.com]

It's like comparing two HOF's, obviously one is better, but it's kind of pointless to decipher which one is better, because they are both great.

Not to mention they play in entirely different systems with very different quarterbacks.

I'll say Smith because I'm a slight homer and he makes some of the most unbelievable catches. What he does after the catch is another trait that separates Smith from most in the league.

[TheRed]

Comparisons can be made for an eternity both players are superb in their own ways. I don't see why some here are all over Fitzgeralds jock as much as they are honestly. Different teams with their own systems and different quarterbacks produce their own results. Randy Moss and Tom Brady anyone.. What did Randy do in Oakland again? Steve Smith is a spectacular WR in his own right.. period.

[WildBill559]

Is it an argument anymore????

Yes.