Would you trade either DWill or Jonathan straight up for...

[jtnc]

No. But I'd trade Sutton and Pike for Kolb.

[ThPantherFan]

We really need a separate section for "what if", or "would you" trade senarios.

I agree. It is fun to speculate, but it gets ridiculous at times. I'm not trying to pooh any posts or posters, but we should have a what if category. I need to go smoke some weed. It's still snowing here in the mountains. It is so nice not to have to get out in this stuff.

[scarface]

Fug no.

[CRA]

the scenario is wrong on some many levels.

Kolb is kinda like Matt Moore.....only people didn't trash him and ignore all the good b/c of a horrific week 1 performance. They just assumed Kolb had a bad day. Kolb isn't worth what Philly wants for him......they would have to give us Kolb and something for Williams. Regardless, Philly wouldn't b/c McCoy is freakin good.

[MWCarolina]

Carolina fans need to QUIT being so crazy. i rather have Clausen then Kolb. There's a reason he lost his job and it's not because he's good. i rather gamble on Cam Newton, Blaine Gabbert, Jake Locker or Ryan Mallett than go after Kolb, Orton or ANY free agent/trade bait quarterback with maybe the exception being Young, but even i dont want him there either, i want Young in Washington.

[ckad79]

I would consider it. It would be tempting.

Thing is, this team has showed an ability to breed good running backs in the past few years. Of course, Rivera and whatever staff he brings in... may change that! Yet, you have to admit that Jim Skipper, while here, did a great job working with our backs.

Trading a good wide receiver is another story, considering they are few and far between with this club! haha

I just don't know how good Kolb is? Both Stewart and Williams have proven how valuable they are. Kolb is still a mystery. That would be my biggest concern.

I would say if one running back had to go, I'd go with Williams. Stewart is a downhill runner and really the only guy we got like him. I have more confidence in Goodson to take over William's duties, than I have in anybody else to replace Stewart.

[SOJA]

not going to happen from either side

[R0CKnR0LLA]

Hey guys I think we should trade Ryan Kalil straight up for Alex Smith.

[BBQ&Beer]

Nope, Kolb isn't worth it.

[MWCarolina]

I would consider it. It would be tempting.

i dont think it's tempting at all. Kolb hasnt shown me anything with a good Eagles team, Same goes with Orton, Orton's put up good numbers with Denver, but i dont like how little he's won in Denver and i consider him average. if the panthers get a new QB either get Vince Young or draft one.

[o803oVaDeR]

Yeah, Lets trade a great RB for David Car V. 2! :confused:

[Jackofalltrades]

Jesus Christ, more of this crap?

[Mr. Scot]

For Kolb? Good lord, no :nonod:

[CRA]

Carolina fans need to QUIT being so crazy. i rather have Clausen then Kolb. There's a reason he lost his job and it's not because he's good. i rather gamble on Cam Newton, Blaine Gabbert, Jake Locker or Ryan Mallett than go after Kolb, Orton or ANY free agent/trade bait quarterback with maybe the exception being Young, but even i dont want him there either, i want Young in Washington.

Um, I would take Kolb anyday of the week over Kolb. Reid dumped McNabb for Kolb.

Kolb lost his job b/c Vick came in and was playing like the best QB in the entire NFL his first few weeks. That is it.