No review?

[PanthersFanNY]

It didn't ruin the game. No way would a 60 yard Hail Mary work against the Steelers Defense. Come on... Just because you wanted to see the game end on a busted Hail Mary doesn't mean the game was ruined.

The ball was rolling out of his hand before his arm went forward. Fumble, game over, better luck next year.

[Brooklyn Bully]

The funniest thing about all this is that most of the people whining about the "non-review" are some of the same people that HATE the "Brady" rule to begin with. When Brady's arm "went forward" during the Oakland Playoff game people said it was not only not ture, but the dumbest rule ever. And now...they love the rule. Jesus.

[top dawg]

The funniest thing about all this is that most of the people whining about the "non-review" are some of the same people that HATE the "Brady" rule to begin with. When Brady's arm "went forward" during the Oakland Playoff game people said it was not only not ture, but the dumbest rule ever. And now...they love the rule. Jesus.

Preach it!

[bleys]

The funniest thing about all this is that most of the people whining about the "non-review" are some of the same people that HATE the "Brady" rule to begin with. When Brady's arm "went forward" during the Oakland Playoff game people said it was not only not ture, but the dumbest rule ever. And now...they love the rule. Jesus.

Absolutely the truth. The Steelers won. It's over. People can bitch, but the game didn't live and die by that play. Besides, I still think it was a fumble. If you don't think the ball came out, well, his arm never went forward on it's own. The hit drove the arm forward...

Regardless, people can whine over this, but in the end, the better team won.

[panthersphan]

Just think how crazy this board would be if that was Jake's arm.. wowza...

"Cardinals quarterback Kurt Warner — who was sacked and lost the ball at the Steelers' 44 with five seconds left — was wondering why it was so hastily determined he fumbled. He thought it was an incompletion.

Warner said his arm was coming forward when the ball was knocked out by Steelers linebacker LaMarr Woodley.

“I was really surprised on that one because I was definitely moving my arm forward to throw the ball,” Warner said. “I thought I’d almost gotten the ball off, so yeah, it does surprise you that in that kind of situation — five seconds to go to decide the Super Bowl — you would think it was something they’d do. "

-Kurt Warner

[bleys]

Just think how crazy this board would be if that was Jake's arm.. wowza...

"Cardinals quarterback Kurt Warner — who was sacked and lost the ball at the Steelers' 44 with five seconds left — was wondering why it was so hastily determined he fumbled. He thought it was an incompletion.

Warner said his arm was coming forward when the ball was knocked out by Steelers linebacker LaMarr Woodley.

“I was really surprised on that one because I was definitely moving my arm forward to throw the ball,” Warner said. “I thought I’d almost gotten the ball off, so yeah, it does surprise you that in that kind of situation — five seconds to go to decide the Super Bowl — you would think it was something they’d do. "

-Kurt Warner

Look at the replay. His arm never goes forward. It starts too, but his mechanics send the ball back again and it gets hit. The ball is not actually moving forward when the ball comes out.

Steelers won.

[panthersphan]

"Steelers won."

Wait...the Steelers won?

[Cat Fanboy]

lol - I dont know if it's all the Steelers fans trying to convince themselves they earned the game or what - but what CANT be denied is the RULES call for an automatic review - and that CANT be done in a 3 second look from upstairs. It's also so obvious that it was incomplete that Olineman that could have jumped on the ball didnt...hello...

Now - I know you guys are smart so however you want to call it, there is no way that call isnt reviewed.

Next - to make the presumption it wouldn't have mattered - ludicrous. It's on the 50 yard line. Add the 15 yard penalty and you are looking at 35yrds with about 15 seconds on the clock.

like the rest who dont have blinders on, I DONT CARE - but that doesnt mean you live in denial.

[SKULL]

I really don't understand all this whinning for a review!

Kurt was scrambling for his frigging life, I'm sure if the review on the field was done and if for some reason the REF was drunk and bought into the idea that WARNER threw an incomplete pass.

Then alot on here would be elated that Kurt now had 5 more seconds to scramble for his life again .

Really this is the STEELERS ,they would Blitz and come hard :eek:

Not the Panthers and a prevent defense .

To Quote John Fox

"IT IS WHAT IT IS "

[bleys]

lol - I dont know if it's all the Steelers fans trying to convince themselves they earned the game or what - but what CANT be denied is the RULES call for an automatic review - and that CANT be done in a 3 second look from upstairs. It's also so obvious that it was incomplete that Olineman that could have jumped on the ball didnt...hello...

Now - I know you guys are smart so however you want to call it, there is no way that call isnt reviewed.

Next - to make the presumption it wouldn't have mattered - ludicrous. It's on the 50 yard line. Add the 15 yard penalty and you are looking at 35yrds with about 15 seconds on the clock.

like the rest who dont have blinders on, I DONT CARE - but that doesnt mean you live in denial.

Regardless of who you're pulling for. it's OBVIOUS if you watch the replay his arm wasn't coming forward. It does for a moment, but then he moves it back and then it gets hit.

Watch closely.

[Cat Fanboy]

Regardless of who you're pulling for. it's OBVIOUS if you watch the replay his arm wasn't coming forward. It does for a moment, but then he moves it back and then it gets hit.

Watch closely.

I don't see that at all - and neither did the Cardinal's who just watched the ball bounce it was so obvious. /whatever.

[bleys]

I don't see that at all - and neither did the Cardinal's who just watched the ball bounce it was so obvious. /whatever.

So be it. The better team won. We can have different opinions, but the Steelers still won. So I guess it's a moot point.

The Cardinals not jumping on the ball was a lack of presence of mind. How many times do you hear the cliche, "don't stop until you hear whistles." Funny that the Steelers still jumped on the ball. How many times do you see players pick up a ball even after the whistles blow?

Anyhow, this can go back and forth forever. And that won't change the outcome.