If Luck stays at Stanford, who is the likely choice?

[Carl Spackler]

I'm not sure if Newton or Fairley will leave school. Supposedly an Auburn recruit told a reporter he was coming to AU because Newton was staying. He's going to have a press conference after the team gets back from Glendale to announce his decision.

[Carl Spackler]

Curious...all you who voted trade down, if that wasn't an option, what player would you pick?

[Miaoww]

If Luck stays in Stanford the Panthers won't have a franchise.

Or at least, that's how I'm reading it.

[The Saltman]

if jimmy clausen is still the starting qb then basically.

[Jhyler12]

cam newton would be my choice easily.

:iagree:

[justin6816]

all of ya are so obessed wit luck and harbaugh what happens if both decied to stay at stanford what then I say we need a DT becasue we could not stop the run this yr and we couldn't get penatration fromthe middle if we can get pentration then our DE could have a better shot a getting more sacks or half sacks so I say DT what we need adn give jimmy a little bit more time to devlope he maybe a bust or he may not be so I say give time to see what the new coasch can do rather than put him off already our coaching sisuation didn't urt him either andour wr were young to so they put matt and jimmy in the dog pile with out any help we could not protect him and our center was to help hime read the D as well so he can direct the line were the bliz was coming from and yes jimmy needs towork on his work habits during the off season

[CLTPanther]

I can't see Newton staying for another year after all the crap that went down.

[rayzor]

all of ya are so obessed wit luck and harbaugh what happens if both decied to stay at stanford what then I say we need a DT becasue we could not stop the run this yr and we couldn't get penatration fromthe middle if we can get pentration then our DE could have a better shot a getting more sacks or half sacks so I say DT what we need adn give jimmy a little bit more time to devlope he maybe a bust or he may not be so I say give time to see what the new coasch can do rather than put him off already our coaching sisuation didn't urt him either andour wr were young to so they put matt and jimmy in the dog pile with out any help we could not protect him and our center was to help hime read the D as well so he can direct the line were the bliz was coming from and yes jimmy needs towork on his work habits during the off season

no periods;didn't read

[Matthias]

You take the shut down corner in PP. If we still need a receiver by season's end, Alshon will be there in 2012. He has way better potential than AJ. Cam Newton is a project.

[wakecooper]

Even if Luck comes out we may not draft him, at least if you buy what Michael Lombardi is selling:

"The Panthers are on the clock with the first pick in the 2011 draft (order for top 20 picks of 2011 NFL Draft). There are indications coming from Carolina that the organization will not draft a quarterback and rely on Jimmy Clausen next season. ... "

Then again, this is the same guy that is still on Josh McDaniels' junk, so I'm not sure he has the highest credibility.

[countryboi]

Even if Luck comes out we may not draft him, at least if you buy what Michael Lombardi is selling:

"The Panthers are on the clock with the first pick in the 2011 draft (order for top 20 picks of 2011 NFL Draft). There are indications coming from Carolina that the organization will not draft a quarterback and rely on Jimmy Clausen next season. ... "

Then again, this is the same guy that is still on Josh McDaniels' junk, so I'm not sure he has the highest credibility.

there is no way that is possible....even if you believe in jimmy you dont pass on luck......what happened to BPA?

[Matthias]

If the FO pass on Luck in favor of Clausen, every Panther fan should officially boycott every Panther game. Let BoA stadium be home to many outsiders. And if we lose the franchise to Los Angeles, so be it. It is what it is.

[Highlandfire]

We will trade out and stockpile picks. Take Locker or Mallet a couple picks lower.

[Udogg]

Without Luck who is going to trade up? There is no one in the draft after him that seems like a bargaining chip to trade up for. Unless something historic happens in combine, why would any team trade up to the first? Maybe swap a 7 or 8th or something like that but for the 1st pick? I don't see it.