2011 Huddle Draft

[C47]

Yeah need to be reasonable trades.

Once we have all the teams accounted for we should take a vote on 3-5 users who are online a good amount of the time that can have veto powers on trade proposals. Those people can communicate via pms if they think a trade is too over the top....

[holderoftruth]

I don't agree with you that it wont work with any players being traded. I think it can work with players being traded there just needs to be firm rules set up beforehand and a committee so to say to veto asinine trade proposals.....

I just think there is a gray area when it comes to asinine trade proposals. For example, a couple pages ago you thought Andre Johnson could be traded. Personally if you got a first rounder for him I wouldn't mind it because it is on par with the Brandon Marshall trade that happen in real life, but it probably would have been veto. Who determines the players that can and cannot be traded, the committee? I would rather do a FA and a draft, with trades involving only picks or everything goes. Just my two cents.

[C47]

I just think there is a gray area when it comes to asinine trade proposals. For example, a couple pages ago you thought Andre Johnson could be traded. Personally if you got a first rounder for him I wouldn't mind it because it is on par with the Brandon Marshall trade that happen in real life, but it probably would have been veto. Who determines the players that can and cannot be traded, the committee? I would rather do a FA and a draft, with trades involving only picks or everything goes. Just my two cents.

It really depends on the owner, depending on the compensation I'm sure a trade involving a marquee player could be agreed to and passed through in this. However, last year we has insane trades (moving Peyton, Rivers, Rogers etc etc for nowhere near their value). I think if you had a group of people who could make sure trades are realistic it would work ok. I'm sure if I moved Andre for a middle to high first and a role player it would probably pass. Although there are Houston fans who think he is pretty much untouchable as I have found out through stalking their message boards in preperation for this.....

[holderoftruth]

It really depends on the owner' date=' depending on the compensation I'm sure a trade involving a marquee player could be agreed to and passed through in this. However, last year we has insane trades (moving Peyton, Rivers, Rogers etc etc for nowhere near their value). I think if you had a group of people who could make sure trades are realistic it would work ok. I'm sure if I moved Andre for a middle to high first and a role player it would probably pass. Although there are Houston fans who think he is pretty much untouchable as I have found out through stalking their message boards in preperation for this.....[/quote']

Last year's trades went fine besides the Charges who had a fire sale on their entire roster and were shipping Pro Bowl players left and right. I don't quite remember who was all involved in the Manning trade and I'm too lazy to look it up, but the Colts received good compensation from that trade including picks that landed them Sam Bradford. I'm just thinking too much into this, I'm sure the trades will be fine. I did the same thing with Patriot message boards last year.

[GaryClaudia]

1. NICK FAIRLEY DT

3. D.J. Williams TE

4. Jeron Johnson S

5. Mike Blanc DT

6. Zach Hurd G/ Stanley Havili FB

[Kevin Greene]

We can lock this thread up too please.