Where do you rank Andy Reid among NFL Head Coaches?

[Cavscout]

Top Ten

[thefuzz]

Probably top 3.

Easy QB system. Aggressive D. Very consistant. Good talent evaluator, not great, but good.

[Mvp2014]

No disrespect to Reid, but I'm not sure you can rightly rank a coach who's never won a Super Bowl ahead of one who has.

I disagree, I'd much rather have Andy Reid than Jon Gruden or Mike Tomlin. But as far as guys who built the team that they won with, thats different

[Darth Biscuit]

He's top 2, based on the past couple of years... looked at the list of current coaches, no real stand outs besides him and Bellicheat, and I hate that f*cker.

[bleys]

I would take the last decade of Philly success under the Panthers instead of a Superbowl.. The NFL is entirely too competitive to think SB or bust.. but constant success that Reid has brought to that city is hard to come by..

and Reid has a great chance to win that SB this year.. They are the best offense in the league with a very good defense to back them up.

[panther4life]

Yeah, I mean a relatively young, successful Super Bowl winning Head Coach might be a good hire for the Panthers. As opposed to one who never has.

I see what you did there..but I have given up hope on Cowher

[theyhateme45]

No disrespect to Reid, but I'm not sure you can rightly rank a coach who's never won a Super Bowl ahead of one who has.

I'll respectfully disagree... For me you have to look at what he did achieve with the talent he had and how consistently he did it.

I believe His team's have WAY over achieved on offense for their talent, and his defense has always been in the upper tier of the NFL. His teams have consistently been relevant in the post season.

Some coaches win super-bowls with talents they should win with... IE shannahan. Doesn't mean shanny is a great or better coach just because he got a ring and he is proving that now. Just mean he took care of what he should have with the best team in the NFL at the time.

I believe Multiple coaches could have won a superbowl with those Denver teams and other teams....

I do not believe other coaches could achieve what Andy has in Philly with his personnel. That's how I evaluate top coaches...

With that said, easily top 3.