Where do you rank Andy Reid among NFL Head Coaches?

[Dpantherman]

Just curious as to what some of you think, when you hear top coaches, I think Reid has been consistent for the most part. He got it right on McNabb and Vick, his personnel moves have been damn good as well, just look at his team. At times he reminds me of Les Miles with some of his decisions, but as a coach, hes definitely top tier, just needs a ring.

[dimbee]

Top 3

[Mvp2014]

I"d say top 5, he is a great players coach and those boys play hard for him. He runs a great system on both sides of the ball.

[mav1234]

top 5 year to year and maybe higher. who do you guys think has been consistently better other than belichick?

[Mvp2014]

top 5 year to year and maybe higher. who do you guys think has been consistently better other than belichick?

ummm no one, he's the standard

[Mr. Scot]

Right now, he falls into the Marty Schottenheimer category (wins a lot of games, can't seal the deal).

Schottenheimer and Dennis Green will remain in that territory permanently. Dungy and Cowher used to be there too but managed to escape.

Reid? Maybe, but not yet.

[Jangler]

The biggest.

[Mr. Scot]

The biggest.

Russ Grimm might contest that title.

Rex and Rob Ryan too.

[frash.exe]

Right now, he falls into the Marty Schottenheimer category (wins a lot of games, can't seal the deal).

Schottenheimer and Dennis Green will remain in that territory permanently. Dungy and Cowher used to be there too but managed to escape.

Reid? Maybe, but not yet.

I don't know if i'd go that far to compare him to Marty

he had an abysmal 5-13 playoff record, and he never reached the superbowl

their winning percentages in the regular season are nearly identical but Reid is 10-8. In my opinion Reid is one of the best coaches to have never won a superbowl

[panther4life]

I was thinking about him the other day. As much as it pains me to accept the facts but I'd have to say Bellicheck is hands down the best active coach. You could very well make the argument that Reid is second best right now.

[Mr. Scot]

I was thinking about him the other day. As much as it pains me to accept the facts but I'd have to say Bellicheck is hands down the best active coach. You could very well make the argument that Reid is second best right now.

No disrespect to Reid, but I'm not sure you can rightly rank a coach who's never won a Super Bowl ahead of one who has.

[Davidson Deac II]

I don't know, consistency does count for something. I think that Reid is a better coach, than Brian Billick or Mike Ditka, both of whom have won Superbowls.

[King Taharqa]

In no way am I saying Reid is the greatest. He has flaws just like any other coach, but he's bar none one of the best offensive minds in the game today, and he will take chances that other coaches wont. Somehow, someway, Philly seems to be in the dance every year under him.

[Kevin Greene]

No disrespect to Reid, but I'm not sure you can rightly rank a coach who's never won a Super Bowl ahead of one who has.

Yeah, I mean a relatively young, successful Super Bowl winning Head Coach might be a good hire for the Panthers. As opposed to one who never has.