If we get Luck, Bring Jake back..

[Baschski]

It's no surprise you support Jake. You still think Godfrey is actually good.

Can't come up with a reasonable response to my argument so you bring up a completely irrelavent and unrelated point to try to discredit me. Desperation moves ftw.

[KillerKat]

Can't come up with a reasonable response to my argument so you bring up a completely irrelavent and unrelated point to try to discredit me. Desperation moves ftw.

Because I already did but you choose to ignore it. The only thing different from my proposal and RB's is that I mentioned Pike/Clausen/Moore as the #3. Here it is right in front of your face for you since you pick and choose what to read.

A good vet that can be the #2 and can pitch in when the #1 goes down is much more beneficial to the team while Pike/Clausen/maybe even Moore is the #3. Then when the vet is gone, the #3 QB can become the #2 and will, if everything goes to plan, become a younger version of the vet that just left and can also pitch in when the #1 goes down. Having a piece of sh** vet in the mix that can't play worth a damn, while taking up a roster spot, does us no good.

besides one of the biggest reasons we let go of Delhomme anyway is because if we kept him, there would be a divided locker room and would be no way this franchise could move forward with someone else under center taking charge. It would just be a huge setback to bring him back. Get over it.

[Baschski]

My arguement had nothing to do with 3rd string, reread.

Sorry, forgot to respond to this part. I understand what you're saying about bringing in a good #2, but the question is whether or not we should bring Jake in as the #3. Sure, you're probably right that "Jake can't play" but my point is that there really aren't any 3rd string QB's who CAN play.

[Baschski]

Because I already did but you choose to ignore it. The only thing different from my proposal and RB's is that I mentioned Pike/Clausen/Moore as the #3. Here it is right in front of your face for you since you pick and choose what to read.

Ok, I did respond to the second part about the possible QB controversy. And you're right, I didn't previously address your first point, but now I just did. What you're saying makes sense and I wouldn't be opposed to bringing in a good vet as #2 (not sure who that would be though). The point I'm making is that if we're looking for a vet to be our #3, with Luck and Clausen as the #1 and the #2, then Jake isn't a bad option.

[KillerKat]

My proposal benefits the team more because it starts a cycle. Vet at QB 2 comes while QB 3 sits and learns. Vet leaves, then the #3 because the vet QB 2 while we have another young QB 3 sitting and learning.

[Baschski]

My proposal benefits the team more because it starts a cycle. Vet at QB 2 comes while QB 3 sits and learns. Vet leaves, then the #3 because the vet QB 2 while we have another young QB 3 sitting and learning.

Makes sense to me. I'm not sure the new coaching staff sends Jimmy to 3rd string though. Who are you thinking would fit this veteran #2 role?

[frash.exe]

if Harbaugh gets hired to be our coach, a guy that played QB in the nfl previously, what does Luck need someone to suck up a roster spot for to mentor him

[KillerKat]

Harbaugh could take up 2 jobs. HC and QB coach. GTFO Rip.

[Baschski]

if Harbaugh gets hired to be our coach, a guy that played QB in the nfl previously, what does Luck need someone to suck up a roster spot for to mentor him

Sure, that makes sense. But if Harbaugh isn't the coach, and there are a lot of options out there, there's a very good chance we bring in a vet. Most coaches aren't going to be comfortable with rookie Luck and 2nd year Clausen as their QB group.

[Raskle]

Wow.. so I guess my idea was not so good to you folks then?

[Baschski]

Wow.. so I guess my idea was not so good to you folks then?

I actually thought it was pretty good, we've just been occupied arguing with each other over here haha.

[Raskle]

I actually thought it was pretty good, we've just been occupied arguing with each other over here haha.

Oh good.. thought I was the fat kid in gym class when it's time to pick the dodgeball teams.

[Udogg]

You guys realize if the starter goes down then Jake would start right? So the question should be "Do you want Jake Delhomme to play QB for the panthers again?".

[Baschski]

You guys realize if the starter goes down then Jake would start right? So the question should be "Do you want Jake Delhomme to play QB for the panthers again?".

No, if the starter goes down then Clausen would start.