If we get Luck, Bring Jake back..

[Dpantherman]

sure why not

NO THANKS!!!!!

[CatMan72]

I'd favor the one day contract thing so he could retire a Panther.

Yeah, I'd like to see that.

[CatMan72]

Don't know why everyone is so offended by this idea. We will bring a veteran QB in. It's not crazy to consider Jake a possibility.

So if our starter goes down, you would feel okay turning to Jake?

[panthers55]

Lets see if Vinny wants to come up from Tampa and be quarterback coach. It certainly would be a good pickup for the team if he wanted to coach. As for Jake he isn't exactly an orthodox QB with a great throw or delivery.

[CarolinaPanthers8789]

So if our starter goes down, you would feel okay turning to Jake?

We have turned to Matt Moore, Jimmy Clausen, Tony Pike, Armanti Edwards (briefly), Keith Null, and Brian St. Pierre this year. Combined they have not thrown more touchdows, won more games, or played in more Super Bowls than Delhomme. I would choose a better argument.

[Dpantherman]

We have turned to Matt Moore, Jimmy Clausen, Tony Pike, Armanti Edwards (briefly), Keith Null, and Brian St. Pierre this year. Combined they have not thrown more touchdows, won more games, or played in more Super Bowls than Delhomme. I would choose a better argument.

What does that have to do with next year?? Bret Favre actually WON a super bowl, should we bribe him out of retirement to play here too?? Jake is done. Why is that so hard to understand? The Browns have demoted him to THIRD. can he contribute in a non playing role? sure why not, but hes done as a starter.

[CarolinaPanthers8789]

What does that have to do with next year?? Bret Favre actually WON a super bowl, should we bribe him out of retirement to play here too?? Jake is done. Why is that so hard to understand? The Browns have demoted him to THIRD. can he contribute in a non playing role? sure why not, but hes done as a starter.

Find me where someone said we wanted him as a starter, if Luck and Clausen went down then yes he would have to play but he is a better option than St. Pierre, Null, Pike, and Moore based on the aspect of NFL EXPERIENCE. No one said they wanted him to start but it wouldn't hurt the Panthers to bring him in as a third string QB.

[CarolinaPanthers8789]

PEOPLE

Quit looking to deep into this thread, this thread is not about Jake being a starter or even a back-up. It is a question of if you would be ok with Jake being the Panthers third string quarterback. We would have Luck, Clausen, and Delhomme. Right now our third string quarterback is Null/St. Pierre now if you can tell me with a straight face that you would rather have St. Pierre or Null as our third string quarterback over Delhomme than you have more problems than one could imagine and thank God you are not a canadite for next years coaching job.

[The Saltman]

I would rather not have delhomme, null, or st pierre as my 3rd string qb.

[Dpantherman]

you don't bring a QB as 3rd string, 2nd string, ANY string, that can't start , its pointless

[PanthersGM305]

Funny I made this happen in Madden 11 Jake came back for two season as a back-up n then retired as a Panther. He is our TD leader with 120 his Int is right up the 3 digit number.

[Starscream]

Tell Jake to retire, then come back here as QB coach.

[Cat'sGrowl]

you don't bring a QB as 3rd string, 2nd string, ANY string, that can't start , its pointless

Jake can start, he did for 3 games and played decent enough for a 3rd stringer.

When I first saw this thread I kind of thought the idea was silly, but once I opened it I really took more of a "why-not?" attitude?

I mean we're paying him all that money anyways..Might as well make him do something around here.

Unless of course we could get our hands on a legitimate veteran commodity, then, well, sure why-not?

[Dpantherman]

put the man in a role on the sidelines. thats it.