McNabb was a bridge/mentor for Luck or Cam in 2011

[CatMan72]

I would love to see us get McNabb as long as the price was right.

[Dro]

I would love to see us get McNabb as long as the price was right.

what do you think of the deal i thought up a few posts higher?

[CatMan72]

Hello, Im a redskins fan(hurts to say it right now) but i have a few questions

say you guys get the number 1 pick would you guys take the deal of

Our First (potential top 6 pick) Mcnabb, Haynseworth, 2012 3rd, 2012 4th

that way you guys get a QB for now.. AND Cam Newton who most believe can be as good as McNabb... AND you get Haynseworth which i know people are iffy on getting him but if he plays in the 4-3 hes ok and quiet and will be a FORCE to open up holes for your LBs...

then you add a 3rd and a 4th in a potentially DEEP class next year with players being scared of the lockout therefor they will return to school...

Also what chances do you guys think you have of re-signing Kalil?

Nope, there's no trade package worth passing up on Luck... he's supposed to be the best QB coming out of the draft since Peyton Manning.

On top of that, I don't think we have ANY interest in Haynesworth and it has nothing to do with his talent.

I think we'll re-sign Kalil, we've got the $ to do it and then some - it's just a matter of whether or not he wants to stay and he's never said anything to make me think he doesn't.

[Darth Biscuit]

Hello, Im a redskins fan(hurts to say it right now) but i have a few questions

say you guys get the number 1 pick would you guys take the deal of

Our First (potential top 6 pick) Mcnabb, Haynseworth, 2012 3rd, 2012 4th

that way you guys get a QB for now.. AND Cam Newton who most believe can be as good as McNabb... AND you get Haynseworth which i know people are iffy on getting him but if he plays in the 4-3 hes ok and quiet and will be a FORCE to open up holes for your LBs...

then you add a 3rd and a 4th in a potentially DEEP class next year with players being scared of the lockout therefor they will return to school...

Also what chances do you guys think you have of re-signing Kalil?

I might take that except for Haynesworth... he's a turd. Having Mcnabb to play a year and mentor Newton would be a good deal.

As far as Kalil, yes we've got to re-sign him to keep the core of the oline together and get a good FA to improve it.

[Dro]

i think the recent media problems and the mishandling of the situation with shanny and haynseworth (mostly shanny) has made Al look bad... he comes to Carolina with a chip on his shoulder and out to prove hes got the talent to be graet... plus the 4-3 is what he wants.. started the whole mess..

[Jangler]

pass. plus his past says JR won't even look his way.

[Baschski]

A playmaker at DT would take our defense to another level...

[Dro]

A playmaker at DT would take our defense to another level...

which is why i think the trade i proposed would work....

you get a VET QB....Future QB... kind of the same play style in both...And a dominant DT to open your defense up.. AND 2 picks in a deep 2012 draft..

[Mr. Scot]

Have you guys seen McNabb this year?

Playing outside of Reid's WCO, he's not the same guy :nonod:

And Haynesworth? Not even at gunpoint!

[Baschski]

which is why i think the trade i proposed would work....

you get a VET QB....Future QB... kind of the same play style in both...And a dominant DT to open your defense up.. AND 2 picks in a deep 2012 draft..

I hear ya, but there's no way that trade actually happens.

[Proudiddy]

If this Luck is so ***** great why the *** does he need a mentor.

He gets the same treatment Clausen gets, no special treatment.

I'm not gonna take my advice on McNabb from David Duke.

Secondly, I suggested this earlier in the season and the thread got pretty big IIRC, most seemed to be on board with it... I definitely am.

Hopefully, JR learned his lesson this year about the importance of true veteran leadership at the QB position... nothing against Matt Moore, b/c I want him back too.

[Dro]

I hear ya, but there's no way that trade actually happens.

i i doubt it to.. it just makes so much sense for you guys... and us...

[pepaw]

A playmaker at DT would take our defense to another level...

Or having an elite QB would have our franchise set for the next 15 years...

[pepaw]

it'd be all worthless if the WR corps aren't upgraded to NFL standards but I think it would be a start for Carolina.

Your WR corps are overrated. Drew is just Godly and Sean can put together a near perfect game plan half the time.