QB even if Luck stays?

[KDawg004]

Would you guys still be dead set on taking a QB if Luck stay at Stanford? I'm not a Newton fan but maybe trade down for someone like Mallett or Locker. Chances are slim we'll be this bad again next season to be in a position to draft Luck.

[mav1234]

depends who is available.

I'd rather have Cam Newton than Mallett or Luck, but I do think we should probably bring in QB help.

It may play out differently though, especially if Clausen wakes up from whatever walking coma he is in.

[MattB]

Yes, but I don't think Newton or Locker are worth taking 1st overall. Ideally you'd try and trade down or maybe try and trade back up into in the teens using next years 1st.

[Cavscout]

We must upgrade the QB position...If Luck stays in school we either have to draft another one or sign a FA

[SuperMan]

If luck stays i'd draft green, and hopefully luck next year.

[Carl Spackler]

If Newton and Luck stay in school, does this mean we're gonna be left with reaching for Jake Locker at #1 or getting Peterson?

[Actionman0z]

I would not reach for another QB at #1 if Luck is not coming out.. Lord help us.

[rayzor]

luck and newton are the only QB prospects that i am interested in at all...even in FA. if we can't get either of those guys then we stick with clausen and wait until first overall the following year and get lucky.

[Actionman0z]

If Luck does stay in, I would just as soon go with Fairley or Peterson. Who knows. BPA, and look to trade a guy or 2 for more picks. I would love to trade Goodson.

[Bruce Wayne]

In my opinion there is only one other QB that is worth the first over-all pick and that is Ryan Mallet. Luck and Mallet are the only 2 complete package QBs.

[Actionman0z]

I have not seen enough of Mallet to say for sure, but on the BCS bowl game breakdown show last night, he was getting love from everyone around there. Does he have character problems?

[Ohio]

Mallett has all the tools that Luck has, and has done it against NFL Talent, unlike Luck.

Locker is just an athlete playing QB, he's not very good

[unicar15]

Mallett has all the tools that Luck has, and has done it against NFL Talent, unlike Luck.

Locker is just an athlete playing QB, he's not very good

I question Mallett's intelligence. If they find out in the interviews that he is a smart kid then take him...If not then IDK what to do. Green? He's probably the most sure thing in the draft if Luck stays in school.

[Lout]

If Luck doesn't declare.. I am trading Steve Smith for a 2nd rounder, and taking Green #1 overall. No QB (other than Luck) is worth taking in the Top 10, let alone the #1 overall pick.