The Quarterback Thread

[Dpantherman]

Okay, this is an on-going argument, and after another outstanding performance by the "Mr. Hair" Tom Brady, where does he rank now and all time. Give me your lists.

[Darth Hater]

Right behind Adam Vinatari....... nah just kidding he's fuggin good.

[FreeDrinkMafia]

Now:

1. - Tom Brady

2. - Michael Vick

3. - Aaron Rodgers

4. - Ben Ruthlessraper

5. - Philip Rivers

All-Time:

1. - Joe Montana

2. - Johnny Unitas

3. - Otto Graham

4. - Sammy Baugh

5. - Tom Brady

[King Farquaad]

Now:

1. Peyton Manning
   
2. Drew Brees
   
3. Tom Brady
   
4. Phillip Rivers
   
5. Michael Vick
   

All-Time:

1. BART STARR
   
2. JOE MONTANA
   
3. SAMMY BAUGH
   
4. OTTO GRAHAM
   
5. TOM BRADY
   
6. JOHNNY UNITAS
   
7. ROGER STAUBACH
   
8. STEVE YOUNG
   
9. PEYTON MANNING
   
10. BRETT FAVRE
    

[King Taharqa]

Ha ha, whoever's "character" that is, I own your soul. You made my day. Thank you.

[Dpantherman]

what the hell?!

[Kevin Greene]

Now:

1. Peyton Manning
   
2. Drew Brees
   
3. Tom Brady
   
4. Phillip Rivers
   
5. Michael Vick
   

All-Time:

1. BART STARR
   
2. JOE MONTANA
   
3. SAMMY BAUGH
   
4. OTTO GRAHAM
   
5. TOM BRADY
   
6. JOHNNY UNITAS
   
7. ROGER STAUBACH
   
8. STEVE YOUNG
   
9. PEYTON MANNING
   
10. BRETT FAVRE
    

Nice username.

Steve Young does not belong on that list.

[Dpantherman]

I can't breathe

[GritsRgreat]

Now 1) Brady

All time? how the hell should i know, most of those old Fers played before i was born. I will say that Montana, Brady and Manning are 3 of the best QB's i've ever seen on the field. Marino and Favre are good but not at the level as the above. To tell the truth, i'm still leaning towards Joe Cool as the best based on todays rules. Its much easier to play QB nowadays than in Montana's

day.

[Cavscout]

He is the best playing the game right now.

I saw Staubach, Bradshaw, Elway, Montana, Theisman, Favre, Manning, Young...as good as some of them were, they were not as good as Brady

I never saw Unitas, Baugh, or Graham so I can't say he would be better than they were

[Fox007]

Everyone is entitled to their opinion, but there is NO WAY in hell Steve Young is a top 10 QB.

[thefuzz]

Why does anyone have Mike Vick in the top 5 active?

Manning

Rivers

Brady

Brees

Rodgers

[Henne Given Sunday]

Did anyone of you ever really watch Marino play? regardless of win/loss. dude had the best physical/mental tools of any qb ever. rocket arm, great touch, great accuracy.....bill walsh, montanas coach said famously.

"montana is the product of a system. dan marino IS a system."

just sayin...

[TheRealDeal]

Rodgers isn't having a good year at all. So much hype and he's underperforming for sure.