Should Vince Young have started for Tennessee today?

[Kevin Greene]

Inquiring minds want to know.

(Assume he's heathy)

Just curious on your thoughts as KT has a thread crapping on Fisher going.

[Delhommey]

The Injured Reserve list is an unforgiving mistress.

[Dpantherman]

hes on IR

[Kevin Greene]

Assume he's healthy

[Dpantherman]

i think hes the best option when healthy. You have Rusty Smith (enough said), and Kerry Collins is 80

[Delhommey]

Who's to say he wouldn't have started if he were healthy?

[mav1234]

Fisher did I think.

Though honestly, Fisher knew he was gone when he said that, so I dunno how his tune woulda changed.

[King Taharqa]

The Injured Reserve list is an unforgiving mistress.

Dude is on IR simply because of the fallout. He probably could've held off surgery on his thumb til after the season. Vince did not want to be pulled and did not want to leave the game. But for the 2nd time in his career, Jeff Fisher successfully used an injury to make a QB change. Something most head coaches dont do. But Fisher has 0 faith in him and pulled the trigger for the 2nd time this season. Fisher said regardless of the injury, no matter what, Vince aint his QB. Im trying to wrap my mind around the fact why he hasnt been fired yet.

[Kevin Greene]

i think hes the best option when healthy. You have Rusty Smith (enough said), and Kerry Collins is 80

Well Collins is out with a bad calf, Smith played like poo and the other QB is Chris Simms.

Maybe the Titans shouldn't have been so hastey to IR Young.

[Kevin Greene]

Fisher did I think.

Though honestly, Fisher knew he was gone when he said that, so I dunno how his tune woulda changed.

Yep

"We had an incident in the locker room, and it was very unfortunate. It's been well documented," Fisher said. "As a result of not only the incident in the locker room but also more importantly the injury to Vince's thumb, Vince is not going to play anymore this season."