Eli Manning or Kitna?

[Brokenbad]

I cant decide!

Manning is going up against a very poor (28th) Jaguar pass defense. He doesnt have 51% of his stats with him either (Nicks and Smith).

John Kitna has been putting up good numbers but faces a number 2 Saints pass defense.

Kitna is projected to score 4 more points than Eli.

Thoughts?

[bleys]

I would have went with Eli.. easily.

even if the defense has a mediocre secondary, a team like NO or Iggles who blitz a lot can keep most QBs unbalanced and off their game.. And Eli is having a pretty good year.. granted we'll see how he does with even less receivers..

[X-Clown]

I'm with Bleys, I would have said Eli.

My quandry is whether I start Eli or Schaub this week...I'm leaning Eli because I have a feeling that the Texans will use the ground game after gaining the lead against Rusty Smith and the Titans and use that rather than going with an air show.

[Panthro]

I have Schaub and think that they will try to work out the kinks theyve been having in the passing game this year. Could be a high scoring affair for the Texans.

[Hawk]

Eli all the way

[Gazi]

With all of his weapon out, Eli is a bad start. They're gonna run, run and then run some more.

Jags D should be good for a fumble or two