Grades: Panthers-Ravens

[Laetitia]

(By Darin Gantt, [email protected]) iReport Card from the Panthers-Ravens game on Nov. 21. /ip/b

More...

[Dpantherman]

QB- F+ ??? must be the TD

[Dpantherman]

F- COACHING: Even if you didn’t think the mid-week decision to start St. Pierre was half-baked, they didn’t do enough to give the team as a whole the best chance to win. Take out the touchdown pass, and he averaged 3.1 yards per attempt. That makes it a miracle Goodson did anything on the ground.The defense continues to start slow and play undisciplined from there.

Read more: http://www.charlotteobserver.com/2010/11/21/1856644/grades-panthers-ravens.html#ixzz15xvXuVXz

[Anybodyhome]

F- COACHING: Even if you didn’t think the mid-week decision to start St. Pierre was half-baked, they didn’t do enough to give the team as a whole the best chance to win. Take out the touchdown pass, and he averaged 3.1 yards per attempt. That makes it a miracle Goodson did anything on the ground.The defense continues to start slow and play undisciplined from there.

But John Fox said St. Pierre gives them the best chance to win. Nowhere did he ever say the coaching staff should "do enough to give the team as a whole the best chance to win" as Gantt claims.

Listen to Fox next time. Listen very carefully because he'll never take any responsibility for a debacle like this team and this season.

[Gazi]

If you follow him on twitter, You know he wanted a column about lowest yards produced by a QB this season. Instead he got another regular Panthers loss. Nothing new to write about.

Gantt F as well

[Carl Spackler]

Fox deserves a Z.

St. Pierre deserves a D. He threw a great ball for a TD and made two bad decisions. Take those picks away and I wouldn't be mad for him starting next week.

[Gazi]

Fox deserves a Z.

St. Pierre deserves a D. He threw a great ball for a TD and made two bad decisions. Take those picks away and I wouldn't be mad for him starting next week.

I'm actually impressed he held on before making these mistakes for so long. He was pressured, hit, WR were dropping balls. And he just doesn't have chemistry with the team. He's only been here 4 days.

I give him a C on a curve grading

[ladypanther]

F- COACHING: [Even if you didn’t think the mid-week decision to start St. Pierre was half-baked, they didn’t do enough to give the team as a whole the best chance to win. T

We knew this long before this game.

[Anybodyhome]

Based purely on his performance relative to Clausen and Moore, I'd give the guy an A+...

...he didn't throw his first pick until the 4th quarter and the team was still almost in it until then.

[Dpantherman]

He threw TWO interceptions on BACK TO BACK drives. both returned for TDs (not necessarily his fault they went for TDs, but he threw them.) F---

[Anybodyhome]

But he did it with less than a week of working with the team.

Jake, Clausen, Moore, Weinke, et al were able to pull off similar plays after they'd been on the roster for a much longer time. Hell, it took Jake many years to figure that out, it took St. Pierre but a few days.

But in some sick sense of not wanting to make this completely smart-ass, he did run the plays he was given (I'm sure he had no audible options with less than a week on the job) and given the situation I'm surprised we didn't see 3 runs and a punt. But think for a minute, would you rather him at least try to get the ball down the field or would you rather have seen 3 runs and a punt?

[Brooklyn Bully]

Take the bizarre pick sixes away and make them normal INTs and there wouldn't be as much heat on Diaper Man. True story. Thankg to the media's love for drama, Fox will have heat the rest of his time here in Charlotte. It really is pointless to grade this team at this point.

[Dpantherman]

take away the Tds he still gets an F. back to back ints? we were down how many points when he threw them?

[err456]

Give St P. a break the guy's arm was tired by the 4th quarter. He'd only thrown like 5 passes or something in his life.