Troy Smith, Vet QB for Next Season

[jramsey4]

I wonder who could have called Smith doing well in this league. Oh yeah me multiple times over the past 2 seasons (hell since his draft). The guy was always dismissed because of his size.

[British_Panther]

I watched his first career start in London live. He did didlly squat for most of the the game missing easy passes while in the pocket. Looks best while on the move or forced into slinging it. Good arm that makes his decision making look better than it actually is. Didn't look too interested in running the ball except at the goal line. Basically he's a weaker, slower Vick who's more commited to passing than Vick used to be. An analysis which a year ago would have been damning. But now I say sign him for a cheap 5 year deal, get him convicted for a felony and then look forward to having an All-Pro QB in 2 years time.

[DynastyRTR]

if he plays as well as he has this season, san fran will re-sign him. possibly long term

[rayzor]

san fran will keep him, esp. since they'll be out of the luck chase.

[MadHatter]

Give me luck with the #1 pick and sign a vet to mentor him.

[King Taharqa]

San Fran isnt gonna keep him. He will be out the door along with their head coach at the end of the season. He will be available for us, but we wont even look his direction. If we did bring him in, it would be as a slot receiver.

[Mr. Scot]

Give me luck with the #1 pick and sign a vet to mentor him.

My take too (Kyle Orton would be my top choice at the moment).

Regarding Smith, like others, I gotta see more than one game's performance.

[mick eye]

I like Troy Smith. I think his lack of height and the hatred some folks may have for Buckeyes have blinded them to his talent. Drew Brees is another short QB and no one doubts him anymore. That said though Kyle Orton is my number 1 pick to bring in. That way Jimmy Clausen can sit back and learn a little instead of being under the microscope.

1st overall draft pick available to desperate team needing franchise QB.

Compensation needed backup vet QB, 1st round pick and 2nd round pick.

Our offseason plans need to include vet QB, RG, LT, DT, and WR. Oh, and a new HC and OC. My choices are

Orton, John Moffit, Derek Sherrod, Jerrell Powe, and Micheal Floyd. Ron Meeks and Kevin Wilson.

[Zaximus]

San Fran isnt gonna keep him. He will be out the door along with their head coach at the end of the season. He will be available for us, but we wont even look his direction. If we did bring him in, it would be as a slot receiver.

.....And here it comes.....

[Fiz]

Call me bias, but Troy can play. He is pretty accurate and very mobile. Usually makes good decisions and is a good leader.

biased. you are biased. You are not yourself a bias.

But Carolina hasn't really made a good decision in the past 2 years. Peppers gone..

bzzzt wrong