Luck or AJ Green?

[Lout]

Drafting Luck is the obvious choice if we have the #1 overall pick. Trade Clausen for a 3rd if we can get it. A great Qb can make WRs look like All Stars. Look at Peyton.. he makes Pierre Garcon and Austen Collie look insane. I guarantee those guys would be nothing on the Carolina Panthers. QB is the answer.. the QB can improve our defense too.. keeping them off the field and keeping them fresh. Everything goes through the QB.

[Lite4Nite]

Vick will be a free agent...somehow convince philly to give him to us as well as other future draft picks(maybe trade our 1st pick?) and then do a little trading with our 3 STUD RBs and get a pick somewhere from 5-10 and grab AJ. Possible?

[Matthias]

Why draft AJ Green when Alshon Jeffrey will be coming out in a year or two?

[Cavscout]

LUCK

and it's not even close

[kdrh5]

AJ Green.

A good coach and a solid vet QB can give you a good offense if you have legit talent.

Yeah, just wont win you a Super Bowl

[SorthNarolina]

No question it should be Luck, if Luck doesn't come out then we should trade down for somebody who wants Cam Newton.

[R0CKnR0LLA]

Clausen doesn't have a good supporting cast

We're not fine at WR

And I'd take Luck

[Ohio]

I argued that he already has a good supporting cast, the offense just looks like poo due to bad play calling and clausen looks like a deer in headlights under center.

You argued that he has a good supporting cast? Have you seen how atrocious our line is?

The entire argument seemed like he was being a huge homer, specifically when he claimed that luck is only a decent Pac-10 QB, and won't be an elite one in the NFL because he only plays in the Pac-10, but Clausen will... I called him a retard then named every good QB to ever come out of the Pac-10 in the history of the NFL.

I have a better one for you, name 1 good QB in the NFL today thats from the Pac 10 not named Aaron Rogers....

To give a rookie only 1 year to play the position and bail on him is ignorant. If we draft Luck he will be given more then 1 year, soooo why is he any different?

[Ohio]

Yeah, just wont win you a Super Bowl

I believe Brad Johnson won a superbowl with the Bucs in 2002, veteran QB. So there goes your theory.

[SuperMan]

I believe Brad Johnson won a superbowl with the Bucs in 2002, veteran QB. So there goes your theory.

Last i checked that was a one of a kind buccaneers defense, same gos for Dilfer and the ravens....

there have also been several rule changes since then that make that style of play obsolete so you really haven't said a thing.

[Jackofalltrades]

Luck or trade down for top DT.

[Nicbsbll2]

I have a better one for you, name 1 good QB in the NFL today thats from the Pac 10 not named Aaron Rogers....

To give a rookie only 1 year to play the position and bail on him is ignorant. If we draft Luck he will be given more then 1 year, soooo why is he any different?

Name the last Notre Dame QB that was worth anything in the NFL...

We will bail on Jimmy this early because he looks absolutely, completely lost out on the field. We will have an entirely new coaching staff, none of which were responsible for drafting Jimmy. Competitively and financially we have very little to lose if we do draft Luck. (Just because we draft Andrew doesn't mean we cut Jimmy)

[Nicbsbll2]

Luck or trade down for top DT.

There will be an outright revolt if Luck comes out and we trade out of the top pick...

[kdrh5]

I believe Brad Johnson won a superbowl with the Bucs in 2002, veteran QB. So there goes your theory.

Oh wow, the exception to the rule, tell me more. Don't leave out the part about the the majority of super bowl teams of the past ten years having elite qbs.