Hurney shouldn't be fired for two main reasons

[Fiz]

Fiz,

Let's just agree that Jake, while one of my favorite players of all time, is at best an average starting QB in this league.

how about no

how about we don't agree on bullshit

how about we look at the situation with an ounce of fuging nuance

how about you don't try to bring me down to your idiotic level

how about you get out

[thefuzz]

Cyberjag,

Comparing the team the AJ Smith has built and the one built by Hurney makes me LOL.

[Fiz]

i mean obviously if marty hurney was any good he would have drafted matt cassell then traded him to the KC Chiefs

[thefuzz]

how about no

how about we don't agree on bullshit

how about we look at the situation with an ounce of f**king nuance

how about you don't try to bring me down to your idiotic level

how about you get out

My idiotic level, are you telling me that Jake Delhomme is the QB that you would hang your hat on if you were a GM?

Lets bring up some career numbers for Jake, not 3 years, and compare him to some others in the league.

I can look at the situation without getting mad at someone poking fun at my opinions. This is a football board, where fans can discuss opinions and thoughts, stop getting upset like a child.

[Kurb]

Fiz and CyberJag present truths.

Revisionist Historians deny the truths.

OR

Ignore them and keep saying the same thing.

[Fiz]

My idiotic level, are you telling me that Jake Delhomme is the QB that you would hang your hat on if you were a GM?

finding a QB off the scrap heap that leads your team to the super bowl and nfc championship game and makes the pro bowl in a 3 year span is pretty impressive.

Lets bring up some career numbers for Jake, not 3 years, and compare him to some others in the league.

let's? as in you want me to? how about you construct an argument instead of saying "heh let's just agree here amiright please don't call me on this"

I can look at the situation without getting mad at someone poking fun at my opinions. This is a football board, where fans can discuss opinions and thoughts, stop getting upset like a child.

stop posting like a fuging child

i went to effort in this thread. I actually constructed an argument. all you can do is nibble at the edges like one of those little fish that ride around on sharks all day and you act shocked when i bitch smack you like the irritating butt fly that you are.

[thefuzz]

Truths and opinions.

Their opinion is that we should keep Hurney, mine is that we need a breath of fresh air in the FO.

I am not saying that Hurney is the best GM, nor we worst, but has just been for a bit too long. Over his body of work, Hurney has been really good for the Panthers, but the last two drafts, and years of personnel choices have soured him, to me.

[Fiz]

Over his body of work, Hurney has been really good for the Panther...years of personnel choices have soured him, to me.

consistent much?

[Kurb]

How exactly can we judge the last two drafts already?

[Fiz]

how can we judge his personnel moves in a year he hasn't been allowed to sign anyone

[tarheelpride]

Oooo one-sided argument :lurk5:

For the record, Hurney is most likely our best bet at this point, despite people's reservations about him. People tend to stick with the bad bad brush off the good with him. I'm not thrilled about him, but he's had more home runs than swings and misses.

[thefuzz]

finding a QB off the scrap heap that leads your team to the super bowl and nfc championship game and makes the pro bowl in a 3 year span is pretty impressive.

let's? as in you want me to? how about you construct an argument instead of saying "heh let's just agree here amiright please don't call me on this"

stop posting like a f**king child

i went to effort in this thread. I actually constructed an argument. all you can do is nibble at the edges like one of those little fish that ride around on sharks all day and you act shocked when i bitch smack you like the irritating butt fly that you are.

I appreciate the effort, I enjoyed reading the thread, I just happen to disagree with your opinion on why we should keep Hurney. That's it. You have your opinions, I have mine.

I have long said that our inability to draft/develop a great QB is what has kept us from winning on a consistent basis. We have been to a SB, but we have also had a roller coaster of a ride from season to season.

The first 5 years of Hurney were IMO very good, the last 2 have not been. You say keep him, I say let him sail away.

[Fiz]

I like to think that thefuzz is compiling some massive effort post with stats and comparisons and such that i can actually respond to but he's probably just going to throw out some butt hurt hop-on-the-cross fest or "hey man it's just like my opinion" and never post in the thread again

[Fiz]

lol called it