Your choice

[Cap'n]

Would you rather have Smith here in Carolina, getting roughly 4 catches for 60 yards per game as we go 4-12 this season and eventually retire without a ring? or watch him win a Super Bowl with an AFC team as he torches defenses like he used to? What we get for him in the trade isn't the point of this post. Just asking as a huge fan of Smitty, what would you like to see made of the rest of his career

[Double34Trouble28]

Whatever small, outside chance he had of making a push for the HOF is going down the drain in this offense.

[YoungPanthers89]

4-12 haha funny

[PanthersPhan18]

Whatever small, outside chance he had of making a push for the HOF is going down the drain in this offense.

Would have been a sure fire HOF with Manning as his qb.

Oh well.

[King Taharqa]

Id like to see him retire a Panther. I'd like to see the franchise give him one last big payday when he's clearly past his prime like they did Jake. I'd like to see him be able to remain in this area after his career is over. I'd like to see a bronze statue of him on Graham St. one day.

[Hugor Hill]

Chargers. smith + Rivers + Gates= winning, alot.

[theyhateme45]

I'm a huge Smith fan and I just want to see him have an opportunity to win, rather that's here or elsewhere. I would love to see him in Indy with Manning opposite Wayne.

[Toker Smurf]

Trade him. He'll be done over the hill before we are good again. The Colts need a WR (or maybe not but). What the hell, I'm so frustrated I can't think straight.

[Mother Grabber]

Let Smith go and find a team that deserves to have him. JR deserves to go down in flames. I feel bad for the players that he's dragging down with him.