Top 5 WRs in the NFL

[The Saltman]

Easy Salty' date=' you've been a mod for less then 24 hours. You have plenty of years left to ban people for not accepting your opinions. No need to try to set records or anything....[/quote']

[C47]

And I was half expecting a threatening ban message. Praise Allah.....

[Dpantherman]

too much authority up in hurr

[X-Clown]

Im going on ability. The only reason Fitz and Marshall's numbers are down bc of their QBs. is White top 5 this season, yes. But the question was top 5 receivers with no specifics. and the top 5 receivers in the game do not include roddy white. sorry. top 10, yes, top 5 no.

85 catches 1202 yards, 14.5 yards per catch, 6 Touchdowns

Those numbers are Roddy White's in 2007 with the combination of Chris Redman and Joey Harrington. So it's not like it's all Matt Ryan.

[Dpantherman]

I don't need to post Brandon Marshall or Larry Fitzgerald's numbers down. They've done it. They've been there. I know what they can do.

Chris Redman had a 90.4 QB rating in 2007. Harrington had a 77.2

Derek Anderson- 62.8 Max Hall- 41.0 Chad Henne- 82.5 ---Brandon Marshall has yet to come on in Miami (like he was), but he'll get there.

[theDIRTYcode]

Brandon Marshall and Roddy Whites last 3 years are mirror images of each other(except Roddy produced the same results with 20 less catches). You want to put Andre Johnson, Larry Fitz, and Reggie Wayne in front of him that's fine, but Roddy comes next.

[X-Clown]

I don't need to post Brandon Marshall or Larry Fitzgerald's numbers down. They've done it. They've been there. I know what they can do.

Chris Redman had a 90.4 QB rating in 2007. Harrington had a 77.2

Derek Anderson- 62.8 Max Hall- 41.0 Chad Henne- 82.5 ---Brandon Marshall has yet to come on in Miami (like he was), but he'll get there.

So bascially your only argument for Marshall is that he's more of a physical specimen, because there's not much of a difference in production. If anything, White's numbers are more impressive in the run heavy system that he's in versus the air it out offense that Marshall was in during his Denver days.

If this argument sounds familiar, it should be - it's the same one that people were making against our own Steve Smith for several years when talking about where he ranks in the pecking order.

[Falcons1stPanthers2nd]

I'm enjoying watching the non-homer win this argument.

[Falcons1stPanthers2nd]

Also if we're arguing on physical specimen's then Jerry Rice isn't a top 5 WR of all time.

[dimbee]

He is averaging 20 yards a catch.

Which only goes to show that stats do not an elite receiver make.

[X-Clown]

Which only goes to show that stats do not an elite receiver make.

Sure it does Dimbee - I mean Kyle Orton is on pace to throw for over 5000 yards....that has nothing at all to do with the fact that he is throwing almost 40 times a game.

[The Saltman]

Brandon Lloyd isn't elite. He is reviving his career but he needs to stay consistent for more than a year to be classified as one.

[God]

brandon lloyd is an absolute monster. having watched every single broncos game the guy has made some unbelievable catches. not top 5 but this year he is.

[Falcons1stPanthers2nd]

brandon lloyd is an absolute monster. having watched every single broncos game the guy has made some unbelievable catches. not top 5 but this year he is.

He has always made sick catches