Serious Thread

[natty]

Out of all the poo play we've seen this season you choose Gamble? Wow.

[Wither]

O-Line.

Out of all the poo play we've seen this season you choose Gamble? Wow.

He wants to be different.

[Delhommey]

How much Schwartz has sucked this year cannot be over emphasized

But he sucked last year, so that's not really a disappointment.

I'd say Stewart, and anyone not named James Anderson involved with our pass rush.

[Chaos]

Couldn't disagree more. Gamble is a huge reason why our pass defense has kept us in games.

As for my pick I am going with Steve Smith. He HAS clearly lost part of his game somewhere, and he routinely tries to make up for it and makes things worse. This team's attitude ride's on his shoulders and he isn't carrying it well.

It's time to face the fact - Steve Smith's game left town with Jake Delhomme. As bad as he was as a QB, I think he had a lot to do with Smitty's fire and determination.

Maybe we all underestimated the delicate relationship between a WR and his QB. 89 + 17 = 106, but 89 - 17 = 72. And we all know 106 is better than 72.

[ladypanther]

Foxy

[Wither]

89 + 17 = 106, but 89 - 17 = 72. And we all know 106 is better than 72.

While I have no real opinion on your theory, that is a horrible line/example/analogy.

[UNCrules2187]

I'd have to go with Stewart. I realize the O-Line and FB play a big role in his numbers, but that doesn't change that fact that he's playing timid, indecisive and worst of all, just plain sluggish out of the blocks. I'm wondering if he's afraid to put too much pressure/strain on the foot with chronic trouble because he's afraid that too much stress on it will cause him to have a lifetime of pain in that foot or what, but he just doesn't look like the same guy.

As an aside, I wasn't onboard with cutting Jake when he was guaranteed money from us and was the only experienced option we had. I'm not saying that he would have played phenomenal or led us to a winning record, but having a capable backup QB is paramount in this league and we definitely screwed the pooch on that front.

[LelouchBritannia]

Tony Fiametta - We got rid of Hoover for HIM!?

Steve Smith - What happened man? Your hands are made of stone.

Offensive Line(Specifically Run Blocking) - From one of the best in the league last year, to one of the worst? Difference? Jeff Otah and Keydrick Vincent. Guess you can probably throw Brad Hoover in there since he blocked like an O-lineman.

[Wither]

Steve Smith - What happened man? Your hands are made of stone.

He's been taking lessons from LaFell.

[Kevin Greene]

Everett Brown, but that's Hurney's fault.

[Dpantherman]

Maybe we all underestimated the delicate relationship between a WR and his QB. 89 + 17 = 106, but 89 - 17 = 72. And we all know 106 is better than 72.

yep...chaos

[Punisher]

He's been taking lessons from LaFell.

I guess that makes him dumb to go along with his bad attitude that he is "always improving".

[Zaximus]

Easily a tie between DWill and Stewart. This O-line is good enough for them to still be dominant. I don't care what anyone says.

[CatMan72]

Jonathan Stewart, hands down.