Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

Its official unofficial semi-official: jimmy clausen to start vs 49ers


Clawsome2

Recommended Posts

QB carousel never works and does more good than harm for the team.

Word mixup? Or do you mean that?

also, P55, Vick/Kolb is not a QB carousel as I meant it in my post(even if it technically could be one) in the way I don't feel the wildcat is a QB carousel. Just a different formation in a sense; in what example you are giving, Kolb and Vick would be running different plays. You are totally correct that in that case it can work very well, though honestly I think the way Vick was playing means that it doesn't matter. Don't think I've seen him be so consistent with his arm ever before.

in the case of a QB carousel here, it'd be the same offense basically just going in circles with the same two QBs. blech. :(

Link to comment
Share on other sites

more harm than good. is what i meant. sorry. i have 4 or 5 things going on and this is one of the things i shouldn't be doing right now.

Word mixup? Or do you mean that?

also, P55, Vick/Kolb is not a QB carousel as I meant it in my post(even if it technically could be one) in the way I don't feel the wildcat is a QB carousel. Just a different formation in a sense; in what example you are giving, Kolb and Vick would be running different plays. You are totally correct that in that case it can work very well, though honestly I think the way Vick was playing means that it doesn't matter. Don't think I've seen him be so consistent with his arm ever before.

in the case of a QB carousel here, it'd be the same offense basically just going in circles with the same two QBs. blech. :(

Link to comment
Share on other sites

But with all the crap talked about Pike, was he honestly the BPA? And why not just sign a free agent to be your backup?
they liked his intangibles. apparently they thought he reminded them of jake personality-wise. they were pretty high on him as were quite a few others. to me he seemed more of a system QB. that was pretty evident from how well the team did when he got hurt.

i'm not defending the pick, btw. i just don't know who we would have gotten there would have been better for the team. it was worth a shot that late in the draft. all draft picks are gambles but the later ones are even more-so. it's just that they are low risk gambles.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...