Defensive Hypothetical

[PhillyB]

All of my brilliant ideas come while sitting on the commode. So do all of my worst ones, so this thread is gonna be hit-or-miss. bear with me.

If we traded Peppers to Oakland for Asomugah and a first or second-round pick, and got Herm Edwards as defensive coordinator, got rid of lucas and started gamble and asomugah, used the traded pick for a scary pass-rusher to take over pep's spot and shored up the DT position with huge guys via the free agency...

we'd have the best defense in the league.

Can you imagine Herm with that kind of talent in his DB's? Can you imagine having a nasty passrush with the front four, forcing throws to guys being covered by them? Our linebacking corps with a healthy connor, beason, davis, and diggs? seward, even?

the mere thought of it is so awesome i have to go to the bathroom again. dammit. discuss.

[chbright]

evan al wont give up a top player and a top pick for pep. wish the old man would though.

[Kurb]

Aso won't leave Oak, and his talent would be wasted here.

[PhillyB]

Aso won't leave Oak, and his talent would be wasted here.

how so?

[Mr. Scot]

Carlos Rogers wants out of Washington after their pickup of DeAngelo Hall, but his attitude may be an issue and they may want as high as a second rounder for him (seems high to me).

[Kurb]

Carlos Rodgers is a good CB.

Not an even trade with Pep tho if thats where you are going.

[stankowalski]

If you're thinking defense when you're sitting on the toilet then you're in the wrong stall.

[Mr. Scot]

Carlos Rodgers is a good CB.

Not an even trade with Pep tho if thats where you are going.

Not where I was going.

Pep and our second rounder for Rogers, their first and a third? Maybe their first, Rogers and Jason Taylor? These are hypotheticals I might consider but still not sure I'd take (nor would I realistically think them possible).

[PhillyB]

If you're thinking defense when you're sitting on the toilet then you're in the wrong stall.

touche.

Pep and our second rounder for Rogers, their first and a third? Maybe their first, Rogers and Jason Taylor? These are hypotheticals I might consider but still not sure I'd take (nor would I realistically think them possible).

I don't see the FO going for taylor... isn't he getting up there in years? plus he strikes me as prone to outside distractions. not a hurney/fox type player IMO.

[stankowalski]

how so?

He would be wasted in our system because we don't use man to man all that much, which is where Asohardname shines.

[PhillyB]

He would be wasted in our system because we don't use man to man all that much, which is where Asohardname shines.

True, but with him we COULD if we wanted to, freeing up safties for some much-needed blitzes, in case our front four can't get it done. and if we pick up Herm as DC, the schemes will change a little bit at least, enough to work it in.

[Mr. Scot]

I don't see the FO going for taylor... isn't he getting up there in years? plus he strikes me as prone to outside distractions. not a hurney/fox type player IMO.

As a long term replacement, no.

As a one year patch allowing the team to wait till next year to get a long term replacement? Maybe.

[TheJza]

Carlos Rodgers is a good CB.

Not an even trade with Pep tho if thats where you are going.

Most Skins fans would disagree with you. I'm neither here nor there, but living in Redskin country...most cant stand him.

I want Aso from Oakland in our backfield. One way or another.

[Jackofalltrades]

I'd take Haynesworth over Aso, move Lucas to NB or just cut him. I'd LOVE to see Herm in Carolina as DC.