If we sign a FA WR

[Panthro]

and AE is not activated will you consider his selection a complete failure? With Mike Williams and Geno Atkins on the board when we traded up I certainly would.

[littlebigman89]

I don't understand why they invested all they did in him and he's inactive every week. He can't make things any worse. He's not learning anything wearing street clothes standing on the sideline.

[rayzor]

and AE is not activated will you consider his selection a complete failure? With Mike Williams and Geno Atkins on the board when we traded up I certainly would.

it depends on if they weren't planning on him being a factor until next year anyway.

i don't think you can really judge players, esp. WRs and QBs, on their rookie year.

[CRA]

it takes most WRs a few years to be NFL ready.

Edwards wasn't drafted to be starting WR in 2010.

[Seamonk]

didn't you hear? AE is gonna be our backup QB next year.

[The Saltman]

I will wait to make any judgments on AE until he plays a game. It is kinda sad tho.

[H2oproof]

it takes most WRs a few years to be NFL ready.

Edwards wasn't drafted to be starting WR in 2010.

but with what we gave up he was expected to contribute

you dont give up a 2nd rounder for a player that you expect to deactivate most of the season

there are plenty of WRs who were drafted after him who are getting plenty of clock, yet AE hasnt seen a snap yet. nobody expects him to be a starter but with what we gave up, we expect him to be out there making catches

[Darth Biscuit]

Too early to call him a bust IMO... certainly not the best use of the pick however.

[Panthro]

I'm not calling him a bust either. I'm calling the selection a complete failure.

[Samuel L. Jackson]

lol Panthro trollin' for AE homers again...

[Floppin]

Considering the pick isn't technically used until next year, I believe you have to at least give it until the end of said year to make a judgement.

The real question is, did we really need another "Panthro hates on AE" thread?

[The Saltman]

I'm not calling him a bust either. I'm calling the selection a complete failure.

with how our season is going it now looks like we need that 2nd round pick more then ever.

[Samuel L. Jackson]

Bottom line is the pick was an extreme reach and risk at the same time... as of right now, it is looking like a boneheaded move...

...coulda got Gilyard too...

[Panthro]

Considering the pick isn't technically used until next year, I believe you have to at least give it until the end of said year to make a judgement.

The real question is, did we really need another "Panthro hates on AE" thread?

We have 2 Wide Receivers out. If we don't activate him and he sees the field then he was a garbage selection and the FO now believes it too.

Name a WR we have selected under Fox that panned out?