Would you rather have

[Peppermint9030]

Dwyane Jarrett or Mike Williams? LOL never thought id be asking this question or responding with Mike Williams, but I dont think its even close...

[Urrymonster]

Are you basing that off Williams' first average game in 4 years?

Jarrett is younger and ignoring their rookie season, has had significantly more yards and catches. The reason I ignore their rookie seasons, was simply that the Lions stuck with Williams even though he was pretty good darn awful. Jarrett could of easily matched the production from Williams, he just had no playing time.