Huddle Myth: the panthers have one of the weakest WR corps of all time.

[The AntiPie]

So you saying that if those teams qb's were without the talent they have on wr, the qb would not struggle?

If you put pierre garcon on the panthers, do you think he would struggle? Hell yeah, he would.

[Catdaddy]

Its the Jonathan Stewart factor, I am telling you. Panthers are undefeated when Stew has 14+ Carries, going back to 08.

Thats not it at all.We are undefeated when we have more points than the other team at the end of the fourth quarter at every game i've ever seen in Charlotte,Clemson,or on the road.

[Dpantherman]

how is it possible to say that one WR corps that has proven success in the NFL is better than Steve steve + several rookies (and Dwayne Jarrett)?

[MaineManPanther]

I believe 100% that our WR corps minus smitty is more talented than, say, the giants' WR group.

Giants Top WR's :

Smith-1220 yards, 7 touchdowns

Knicks-790 yards, 6 touchdowns

Manningham 822 yards, 5 touchdowns

Carolinas Top WR's (minus Smith as you said)

Jarret -196 yards 1 td

Lafell- Rookie

Tell me what makes you belive the giants wr's our worse then us?

[Cat'sGrowl]

[Jrock3016]

If you put pierre garcon on the panthers, do you think he would struggle? Hell yeah, he would.

And how would you figure that. By using your crude imagination? by the way what has matt struggled on? Difficulty finding any open receivers when there are not any?

[marcopolo]

Hakeem Nicks was a rookie last year... do you see any of our rookies putting up 790 yrds and 6 TDs?

[KillerKat]

isn't this trolling?

[Squirrel]

isn't this trolling?

Yes. Was waiting to see if it actually turned into a decent conversation.

[Jrock3016]

isn't this trolling?

Still a little new...define trolling for me?

[The AntiPie]

Giants Top WR's :

Smith-1220 yards, 7 touchdowns

Knicks-790 yards, 6 touchdowns

Manningham 822 yards, 5 touchdowns

Carolinas Top WR's (minus Smith as you said)

Jarret -196 yards 1 td

Lafell- Rookie

Tell me what makes you belive the giants wr's our worse then us?

Having an elite qb throwing the ball does wonders for stats. See: the pierre garcon post.

The giants have a group of WRs that run awful routes, not particularly big, not particularly fast, not particularly good at getting YACs. And yet they don't have much trouble moving the chains, do they?

[Dpantherman]

Eli Manning an elite QB?

[KillerKat]

lmaoooo that made my night hahahhaa

[The AntiPie]

Hakeem Nicks was a rookie last year... do you see any of our rookies putting up 790 yrds and 6 TDs?

Again, quoting stats = pretty weak. Giants WR stats are all about how well Eli is playing, because they sure don't do much on their own..