Charlie Campbell Pt. 2

[jayboogieman]

6 minutes ago, TD alt said:

Stop worrying. This isn't going to happen. 

It is a very Tepper Era Panthers thing to do.

[CPF4LIFE]

Stewart is a perfect example of a player who's stats don't tell the whole story. He has all the traits for a pro DE. Nobody on that A&M team piled up sacks. Hell, Scourton had only 5 and is also considered a top 20 pick. So it's definitely more potential than production. But far as pressuring the qb production he does it really well. We had nobody that could do that last year,  the sacks will come. 

[csx]

13 minutes ago, TD alt said:

Stop worrying. This isn't going to happen. 

Why worry about any of it?

[ColumbusCounty]

Yea idunno... taking into account that last year we picked a raw WR with only 1 year of solid production and an injured running back with our 2 top 50 picks, surely Dan wouldn't use a top 10 pick on a raw developmental player. 

Sadly I can see it happening.  

 

[jfra78]

So when he picks Walker, can we stop acting like this guy has inside info on who the Panthers are gonna take

[CatalystNX]

I mean, the guy is an athletic freak. I'd prefer someone with better production, but I'd rather have Stewart than Mykel Williams.

[Sean Payton's Vicodin]

24 minutes ago, jfra78 said:

So when he picks Walker, can we stop acting like this guy has inside info on who the Panthers are gonna take

He's nailed the Panthers 1st round picks for like, a decade at this point. Until he's wrong there is no reason to doubt him. I don't want this to be true but Charlie wouldn't change it unless he got a scoop.

[Shocker]

Stewart is a perfect athlete that has no idea how to play football.  I hope we aren’t this dumb.

That said if TMac is there I think we take him.

Edited 20 hours ago by Shocker

[jfra78]

I mean if the plan is to go to 4-3 then it makes more sense

[ECHornet]

3 minutes ago, Shocker said:

Stewart is a perfect athlete that has no idea how to play football.  I hope we aren’t this dumb.

That said if TMac is there I think we take him.

I would like TMac to be the pick, but I’m fine with Stewart. He might not blow us away his rookie year, but he’ll be a really good player for us for a long time. 
 

My nightmare draft scenario is we pass on TMac and the Saints select him and we have to deal with another Mike Evans type WR for the next decade. 

[LinvilleGorge]

1 hour ago, CPF4LIFE said:

Stewart is a perfect example of a player who's stats don't tell the whole story. He has all the traits for a pro DE. Nobody on that A&M team piled up sacks. Hell, Scourton had only 5 and is also considered a top 20 pick. So it's definitely more potential than production. But far as pressuring the qb production he does it really well. We had nobody that could do that last year,  the sacks will come. 

5 is more than Stewart had his entire career. LOL

The thing the vast majority of 1st round busts have in common is that they have all the traits for a pro player.

 

[LinvilleGorge]

3 hours ago, jfra78 said:

Imagine picking these stats over Walker's.  Walker just ticks all the boxes

I'm not completely sold on Walker but if I'm forced to pick between Stewart and Walker I'm taking Walker all day everyday.

[Navy_football]

1 hour ago, CPF4LIFE said:

Stewart is a perfect example of a player who's stats don't tell the whole story. He has all the traits for a pro DE. Nobody on that A&M team piled up sacks. Hell, Scourton had only 5 and is also considered a top 20 pick. So it's definitely more potential than production. But far as pressuring the qb production he does it really well. We had nobody that could do that last year,  the sacks will come. 

Nick Scourton looks like a better player than Stewart. Watch a game and tell me which one looks like the better player. Stewart's hype is driven by physical measureables only. He is not that good of a football player. Could he learn with the right coaching? Possibly. But that risk is too high with pick #8.

Pick #20+ is more reasonable. 

[Adb6368]

He’s Mykel Williams if you take away any highlights on the field during the year