The Athletic - Post-Combine Consensus Big Board - 3/17

[Bear Hands]

They gather rankings from both inside & outside their org and pull it all together.  First big updated post-combine and all.

https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/6203610/2025/03/17/nfl-draft-2025-consensus-big-board-armand-membou/

Snip:

Quote

1. Abdul Carter EDGE Penn State

2. Travis Hunter CB Colorado

3. Ashton Jeanty RB Boise State

4. Mason Graham DT Michigan (interview/meeting)

5. Tyler Warren TE Penn State

6. Will Johnson CB Michigan 

7. Tet McMillan WR Arizona

8. Armand Membou OT Missouri

9. Will Campbell OT LSU

10. Jalon Walker LB UGA (interview/meeting)

11. Colston Loveland TE Michigan

12. Mykel Williams DE/EDGE UGA

13. Cam Ward QB Miami

14. Mike Green EDGE Marshall

15. Jahdae Barron CB Texas

16. Kelvin Banks Jr OT Texas

17. Shemar Stewart EDGE Texas A&M (interview/meeting)

18. Luther Burden III WR Missouri

19. James Pearce Jr. EDGE Tennessee

20. Josh Simmons OT Ohio State

21. Walter Nolen DT Ole Miss

22. Jihaad Campbell LB Alabama

23. Matthew Golden WR Texas

Highlighting potential targets that have been either rumored or often mocked for us.  

[Jon Snow]

Going off those visits one would think they are interested in Johnson or McMillan if they are there at 8. If those 2 or gone then maybe Walker if they cannot trade down a couple of spots.

Edited 4 hours ago by Jon Snow

[jfra78]

Hope it's Walker, but if Graham drops i couldn't see us passing up on him

[LinvilleGorge]

Graham, T-Mac, Walker, Warren, or trade down.

[Lame Duck]

2 minutes ago, LinvilleGorge said:

Graham, T-Mac, Walker, Warren, or trade down.

My list as well.  Graham would be amazing but I bet he’s gone.

[jayboogieman]

59 minutes ago, Bear Hands said:

5. Tyler Warren TE Penn State

[zacka77ack]

Looking like the Panthers get will get a player that is both a need and BPA; sitting pretty at 8.

[Swaggasaurus]

That’s crazy because Cam Ward is elite. He must smell bad or something. At worst he’s #4 on this list. It ain’t adding up for me.

[NAS]

Tet McMillan come on down

[Jon Snow]

29 minutes ago, Swaggasaurus said:

That’s crazy because Cam Ward is elite. He must smell bad or something. At worst he’s #4 on this list. It ain’t adding up for me.

Apparently not. Not sure how he smells but he is far from elite and that is not an isolated opinion. Just based on what little film I've seen on him he needs a lot of work, I mean A LOT. He's not a sure thing.

Edited 3 hours ago by Jon Snow

[PadresPanthersFan]

At first I was vehemently against t Mac. But seeing the insane prices wr have been going for if they believe Bryce is the guy and if t mac is the #1 wr they have on the board then get him so we have a #1 wr on a rookie contract as they're now a  30-40 mill a year position 

[Mistuh Jones]

1 minute ago, PadresPanthersFan said:

At first I was vehemently against t Mac. But seeing the insane prices wr have been going for if they believe Bryce is the guy and if t mac is the #1 wr they have on the board then get him so we have a #1 wr on a rookie contract as they're now a  30-40 mill a year position 

I mean, really hard to disagree with you now. 

[CanadianCat]

Will Johnson is starting to grow on me.. 

[Donald LaFell]

2 minutes ago, CanadianCat said:

Will Johnson is starting to grow on me.. 

it makes sense when you are in nickel most of the time and you can’t trust if Horn will be healthy