Williams or Stewart???

[Doyle]

This is like asking me which of my kids I love more...

Thats funny. I swear I was about to make the same thread but it was going to be who is better. I have to say I'm starting to lean team Stewart. He's like Ricky Williams in his prime minus the dope.

[IRONMAN]

This is like asking me which of my kids I love more...

everyone has a kid they like a little more than the other one.

[JungleCat]

Whichever one has the least amount of injuries.

[Future of the Funchise]

Left Nut or Right Nut

Which do you prefer?

[Any_Given_Sunday]

I like french fries

[Wither]

Left Nut or Right Nut

Which do you prefer?

They both get the job done. Sometimes too effectively.

[Humble Pie]

D-Will for the season.

Stewart for the future.

[DudeNamedJeremy]

it's gonna be a sad, sad day if we ever lose one of them. i'd like to see them both retire panthers

[smash_n_dash]

If I were in control, I'd trade Stewart since he'd probably get more value, keep Williams since he has a good 4 solid years left. During that period, find a competent replacement for Stewart. Hopefully with trading away Stewart, we'd be able to secure a guaranteed #2 WR (someone better than who we have now) or a stud DT/DE. The only way this would turn out bad is if Moore sucks, we have to rely more on the run, Williams gets hurt and Goodson/Sutton can't run.

[ChucktownK]

Big Tittie Nipples

[Cat]

Health is the biggest factor.

I love them both, how awesome is it that we have 2 really fuging good rbs. It makes me happy

[The Saltman]

I'm happy that your happy.

[The Don]

i'm happy that you're happy that he's happy because we have two stud running backs. regardless of who has the better season, we're gonna f*ckin' pown teams all season. it's gonna be great. can't wait to see what DW and J-Stew do to the Browns defense :willy_nilly:

[CRA]

If I were in control, I'd trade Stewart since he'd probably get more value, keep Williams since he has a good 4 solid years left. During that period, find a competent replacement for Stewart. Hopefully with trading away Stewart, we'd be able to secure a guaranteed #2 WR (someone better than who we have now) or a stud DT/DE. The only way this would turn out bad is if Moore sucks, we have to rely more on the run, Williams gets hurt and Goodson/Sutton can't run.

Williams would be 31 in that scenario (pending we don't miss a year of play). IMO, I have hard time seeing them split up the duo that way as they would be expecting a 29, 30, and 31 year old RB to be the bulk of the ground game.

There are very few rare expections where those years don't almost automatically signal the downhill fall of RBs (even great ones). Granted Williams had a few light years early on but he came into the NFL with probably more mileage than any RB I can think of in a long time.