Top 10 Panthers of ALL TIME

[Matt Foley]

Walls was one of the best five tight ends ever when he retired. Smitty might get there, but needs a great QB. Kasay is top 10 among kickers. Bates was one of the best return men ever.

[Jangler]

[coxc63]

Damn I forgot about Kasay. Yea you can question the age of some of the posters on here, I've been a panther fan since I were a kid. I was only 5 when the panthers kicked off their first season, and been following them ever since. I've always looked up to Walls and played TE in high school to try and duplicate him. I can't tell you who took the first snap at the first panther game ever, I know it wasn't Collins, but I do know that he chokes in the redzone and Walls bailed him out on multiple occassions. I don't remember much from the 90's football years, until I watch highlights. Minter does belong on the list not only because of the person he is but he played gis heart out. Doesn't he hold the record for most Ints. Returned for TDs in panthers history.

[Squirrel]

Julius Peppers

Kevin Greene

Eric Davis

Mike Minter

John Kasay

Steve Smith

Muhsin Muhammad

DeAngelo Williams

Jake Delhomme

Steve Beuerlein

No order just the best.

Jake just because of the length he was around.

[Zod]

Anyone who puts Minter in there is listing favorite players and not best players. Minter was always an average safety.

[Matt Foley]

Minter is one of the top three greatest guys to play for the Panthers, but not top 10 players. He had five pretty good years. Never made a Pro Bowl. There have simply been too many really good players ahead of him. Hell, I could have put Todd Sauerbrun on my list. He's one of the best punters of all time, and his years in Carolina were his best.

[Squirrel]

Anyone who puts Minter in there is listing favorite players and not best players. Minter was always an average safety.

Speaking of which Gamble only needs 2 int to be all time leader for the Panthers.

[Zod]

Jeff Mitchell?

[beastson]

Gross, Hoover, Moose?

Tim Biakabutuka? lmao

[Doyle]

What is the list based on? Talent alone. Lonegevity. How they conducted themselves as a person off the field? It could be argued many ways. I do think Minter deserves to be on the list in my opinion but is more like an 8-10 spot.

[Peppermint9030]

When I say ALL TIME GREATS Im not just talking about probowls... He Is an exact representation of what Carolina looks for in a player he was that 10 year player who never left, and gave EVERYTHING he had! Thats why Moose isnt on here... He left for the $. He also made some VERY memorable plays... How can you have 118 tackles, 3 ff's, 2 int's, and a td and not make the probowl? That baffles me.

[Peppermint9030]

I should NOT have put Jenkins on there I was just thinking of the superbowl run... Should be Kasay im changing it.

[Highlandfire]

Walls was one of the best five tight ends ever when he retired. Smitty might get there, but needs a great QB. Kasay is top 10 among kickers. Bates was one of the best return men ever.

+1

[beastson]

When I say ALL TIME GREATS Im not just talking about probowls... He Is an exact representation of what Carolina looks for in a player he was that 10 year player who never left, and gave EVERYTHING he had! Thats why Moose isnt on here... He left for the $. He also made some VERY memorable plays... How can you have 118 tackles, 3 ff's, 2 int's, and a td and not make the probowl? That baffles me.

? Moose came back and retired as a PANTHER

Pep left