Jump to content

  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

Rank the all-time Panther QBs

Carl Spackler

By Carl Spackler,
in Carolina Panthers

Recommended Posts

brandon_87 Newbie

brandon_87

Posted
Posted

By their contributions it isn't close.

Jake was our most successful and it isn't even close.

Collins had the second most success but had no heart.

Buerelein was our most talented quarterback.

Vinnie was the most knowledgeable.

Everyone else isn't worth ranking or didn't play enough to be ranked (like Moore who hasn't played a whole season).

and Vinnie did?

Link to comment
Share on other sites
panthers55 Grand Master

panthers55

Posted
Posted

and Vinnie did?

Played for 20 seasons, only a partial for us. His intelligence came from knowledge of the game. Moore hasn't been around long enough to have much awaremenss of our offense let alone what other folks are doing. Vinny played in several systems.

Your post is a total fail.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
PantherDude Newbie

PantherDude

Posted
Posted

Jake Delhomme #1

Steve Beuerlein #2

Matt Moore #3

Vinny Testaverde#4

Rodney Peete #5

ChrisWeinkie #6

Frank Reich #7

Good pick there, but I wouldn't put Moore as #3, since he never play a game as a full time starter. Same for Vinny too.

My list would go like this from the best at #1.

1.) Jake Delhomme

2.) Steve Beuerlein

3.) Kerry Collins (until he later collapse during the middle of his 3rd season here)

4.) Chris Weinkie

5.) Rodney Peete

6.) Frank Reich

I'm going by what I've seen on the field.

But what if Moore start to become our Derek Anderson?? That is quite homerism to put Moore as better than Jake, 'cause he never play a full season before as a starter. Wait until he play as starter here for few seasons before you start saying he is better than Jake or not. Moore may look better than Jake during Jake's last season here, but this thread is about all-time QB & Moore haven't got there yet. :P

Link to comment
Share on other sites
OneBadassCat Newbie

OneBadassCat

Posted
Posted

Good pick there, but I wouldn't put Moore as #3, since he never play a game as a full time starter. Same for Vinny too.

My list would go like this from the best at #1.

1.) Jake Delhomme

2.) Steve Beuerlein

3.) Kerry Collins (until he later collapse during the middle of his 3rd season here)

4.) Chris Weinkie

5.) Rodney Peete

6.) Frank Reich

But what if Moore start to become our Derek Anderson?? That is quite homerism to put Moore as better than Jake, 'cause he never play a full season before as a starter. Wait until he play as starter here for few seasons before you start saying he is better than Jake or not. Moore may look better than Jake during Jake's last season here, but this thread is about all-time QB & Moore haven't got there yet. :P

Likewise, every game Moore has started in he has played well. When Jake was in his 03/04 form he was damn good. His accuracy was probably top of the league, but his pocket presence and awareness has always been terrible. Jake will always be the 2 mins QB king imo but you could also make the case that the reason we had so many close games was because of him also. Particularly the 08 season.

Though I will say that Jake delivered the best QB season performance back in 2004 for a panthers QB, probably tied with Beurelien there. He rallied that squad and it was inspiring.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
KillerKat Grand Master

KillerKat

Posted
Posted

Do you know who supposedly has talent? Jay Cutler.

Yeah but Beuerlein was our most talented and most skilled QB. It's not his fault that he didn't have a team around him like Jake has had (when I say team Im talking Offense and Defense). I bet if Jake started when Beuerlein did (98-00), Jake would'nt have as much success. But if Beuerlein started the many years Jake has (03-09), he would've had just as much if not more success. I judge on on the field play instead of emotional worth.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Razeyfingers Newbie

Razeyfingers

Posted
Posted

I think it is absolutely hilarious that people are actually ranking Testeverde,....

I think its even more hilarious that people are actually ranking Moore. Im sure he will have his spot when he's done here . . . but ranking him now? Thats some funny chit mang.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Icege
      Serious Thoughts Fellas What numbers would Bryce..

      By Icege · Posted

      Agreed. A healthy bit from column A (stats) and column B (film) paints the most accurate picture, which is currently that Bryce is not performing up to the standard a 1st round QB (let alone drafted #1 overall) is expected to (statistically). When we dig into the film to see why, we see that while he's having his struggles (not stepping up in the pocket, bailing out early, hesitating on some throws, making occasional bad reads, etc) the team that surrounded him last season was simply awful. Bottom 5 defense, bottom 5 OL, bottom 5 weapons... but somehow one player has to overcome ALL of that in their rookie season? Yeesh... Taking this season into consideration, he started where he left off last season and was rightfully benched. Since starting again, the team has gotten on its first winning streak in a few years and he's made good plays to keep them in the game. Is he lighting it up? Nah... but he is beginning to show the reason so many draftniks had him as QB1a for his class. Re: what the team does next season... who friggin knows anymore at this point T_T. Resign Dalton? Sign Jones? Draft somebody in the mid-to-late rounds? Go with another UFA? Maybe grab an FA that can compete with Bryce for the starting position and draft a rookie to sit and develop? Might be best of both worlds for the team, but ugh... not a fun position to still be in with question marks throughout the position group.
    • kungfoodude
      Serious Thoughts Fellas What numbers would Bryce..

      By kungfoodude · Posted

      Yeah, this is basically the same as asking, "What if Bryce Young suddenly had Patrick Mahomes brain, how would he do?" It isn't happening. This ship is beyond sailed. Send him somewhere else, let us move on and him move on. 
    • SmokinwithWilly
      If you wanted Danny Dimes here’s the chance

      By SmokinwithWilly · Posted

      Dalton is too close to starting right now. If it hadn't been for a car accident, he still would be. Switching Dalton for Jones does nothing except reduce the backup's age by a decade. One is in his NFL prime, the other is almost in his NFL grave. Not a horrible move if you're trying to improve the team. We've got to get better as a team and a lateral move like that would improve the team. The problem isn't that he's close to starting. The problem is we have a GM that signed off on BY and didn't bring in any serious QB competition for camp, a HC that said yeah, he's my guy until BY poo the bed so bad he couldn't start him, and an offense that's limited because BY can't make all the throws a normal NFL QB can.  The problem isn't that Jones could be an improvement as a backup QB. The problem is he could be better than our "franchise" QB. 
×
×
  • Create New...