Rank the all-time Panther QBs

[panthers55]

By their contributions it isn't close.

Jake was our most successful and it isn't even close.

Collins had the second most success but had no heart.

Buerelein was our most talented quarterback.

Vinnie was the most knowledgeable.

Everyone else isn't worth ranking or didn't play enough to be ranked (like Moore who hasn't played a whole season).

[brandon_87]

Jake

Buerlein

Collins

Everyone else. No one else has done enough or they were to bad to be mentioned.

perfectly said, but moore has got to be right behind the top 3 simply because what he has shown while he has played

[Dpantherman]

Its not that hard.

1)Delhomme

2)Buerelein

3)Moore (i think hes that good now, and will surpass Jake eventually)

4) Collins

the rest really dont matter

[Mr. Scot]

Delhomme

Beuerlein

Collins

Peete

Testaverde

Reich

Weinke

I'd be tempted to rank Peete above Collins, but it's a tough call.

Moore is still largely an unknown. Ask me again where he ranks after this season's over. Likewise, we may not know much about Clausen or Pike for a while.

The rest? Throw 'em in a hat and pick names one at a time.

[Jangler]

Carr was the most fashionable.

[Doc Holiday]

To say any qb not named Jake delhomme is the panthers all time best qb, would be as off the wall as saying the patriots didn't win 3 super bowls.

[KillerKat]

To say any qb not named Jake delhomme is the panthers all time best qb, would be as off the wall as saying the patriots didn't win 3 super bowls.

Not if you're judging by talent

[1789Cardiac Cats9020]

I'm going by what I've seen on the field.

Consider changing your name to OneBlindassCat

[1789Cardiac Cats9020]

Not if you're judging by talent

Do you know who supposedly has talent? Jay Cutler.

[Khyber53]

Delhomme

Beurlein

Collins

Peete

Weinke

[Happy Panther]

If you are going to rank Moore as a top all time QB you may as well put Clausen up there too

[Carl Spackler]

Never ceases to amaze me how before January 2009, 95% of the people on here would have Jake #1. It pisses me off to see how fickle fans are. Four+ good seasons, one half of a bad season and people say he was never good. I've seen people wearing Jake jerseys rip them off at games when he would throw an INT, then proudly put them back on after the next drive where he threw a TD pass.

[Bobby]

Jake is first, and it isn't even close. At all. Chris Weinke has awesome mechanics and he was 6'6" and built like a brick house. Jake actually won games.

1. Delhomme

2. Beureline

3. Peete

4. Moore

5. Vinny

After that I don't care. I guess Craig would be 6th because he used to be a preseason superstar. f**k Kerry Collins though.

[Cyberjag]

Do you know who supposedly has talent? Jay Cutler.

Todd Marinovich, Ryan Leaf, Jamarcus Russell--tons of talent in that group too.

I like Matt Moore, but I think David Carr would have gone 6-2 with the defensive performances that he's enjoyed. He hasn't been around long enough to be in this discussion.

Chris Weinke probably had more talent than Jake, was he a better QB?