DeAngelo or Stewart

[Ohio]

If you could only have one playing for the Panthers, which one would you pick and why? Here is my opinion/comparison of their attributes.

Speed- DeAngelo

Receiving- DeAngelo

Running between the tackles- Stewart

Goaline- Stewart

Breaking tackles- Stewart

Elusiveness- DeAngelo

Lack of Injuries- Stewart

No I love both of these guys, and want both of them on Carolina for the next 10 years, but if I had to pick 1, Im going with Stewart based off of his running between the tackles and lack of injuries. The way he played against Minnesota really showed his toughness and heart against the best d-line in the game.

[The Saltman]

Deangelo Stewart

[Panthro]

Age is a good RB's worst enemy

I'll take stewart

[The NFL Shield At Midfield]

Push comes to shove, Stewart. His longevity would probably be damaged without Williams though.

[Raskle]

Stewie.. this is really a debate extension of which do you find better to have.. a Power RB or a Speed RB? Or who was better... Jim Brown or Walter Payton?

Not comparing our two to either of those guys, but in concept, it's the same argument.

[Guild]

Stewart only because of age and long term strategy. Williams in a one shot kind of thing.

[OneBadassCat]

Stewart is a speed and power RB.

[Ohio]

Stewart is a speed and power RB.

You're right. Reminds me of Stephen Davis with a more speed, and just a little less power.

[Brokenbad]

This is like asking "tits or ass".

[The Saltman]

ass

[Brokenbad]

ass

As long as there is a vagina I could care less.

[eViL jEsTeR]

This is like asking "tits or ass".

( o Y o ) :ihih:

[The Saltman]

As long as there is a vagina I could care less.

liar

[CarolinaPanthers8789]

If you could only have one playing for the Panthers, which one would you pick and why? Here is my opinion/comparison of their attributes.

Speed- DeAngelo

Receiving- DeAngelo

Running between the tackles- Stewart

Goaline- Stewart

Breaking tackles- Stewart

Elusiveness- DeAngelo

Lack of Injuries- Stewart

No I love both of these guys, and want both of them on Carolina for the next 10 years, but if I had to pick 1, Im going with Stewart based off of his running between the tackles and lack of injuries. The way he played against Minnesota really showed his toughness and heart against the best d-line in the game.

I think lack of injuries is a toss up. I know D-Will missed the last 3 or 4 games last season, but Stewies Achilles has been a hinderance ever since he first arrived in Carolina.

Honestly if I had to pick one it would be D-Will because there are not that many runningbacks that can rely on speed and agility in the NFL. When I think of speed and agility the only one's that come to mind are Adrian Peterson, Chris Johnson, Thomas Jones, and DeAngelo Williams.

Now when it comes to big bruiser backs you have a lot more options and they are a lot more common in the NFL. In today's NFL you have guys like Steven Jackson, Maurice Jones-Drew, Jonathan Stewart, Ricky Williams, Ryan Grant, Cedric Benson, Rashard Mendenhall, Marion Barber, Matt Forte, Michael Turner, Brandon Jacobs, Beanie Wells, Kevin Smith, and Laurence Maroney.

I base my decision on which athlete is harder to find and in my opinion it is DeAngelo Williams.

SIDE NOTE: On a side note I would like the Panthers to cut Mike Goodson, Josh Vaughan, and Tony Fiametta and carry a loaded backfield.

RB- DeAngelo Williams (You already know him)

RB- Jonathan Stewart (You already know him)

RB- Daniel Porter (He was a stud in college and reminds me of AP)

FB- Tyrell Sutton (Proved he is a better option at FB than Fiametta)

FB- Rashawn Jackson (In my opinion he was the best FB in the draft class)