"Objective" Position Battle Panthers vs Saint

[koolkatluke]

I started this with the Falcons and I will do the rest of our Division Rivals and then most of our opponets this year. Now it's time too see how we match up with the Champs.

QB= Saints= Top 3 QB vs 2 young unknowns not even close right now. Breeus wins this match up himself.

RB =Panthers= 2 of the best RB in the league on the same team nuff said.

Side note what if the Saints would have taken DWill instead of Bush 2nd overall? Scary!!!!

FB=Saints= (no Hooooooove) means no FB on this roster has Gametime exp. the saints don't have that problem.

TE = saints = Shockey vs. 3 guys who combine and form "Voltron and avg. Te". Seriously Rosario or Barndage need too step up so we win 1 of these TE matchups.

WR = Saints= We have the best WR in the division they have the best WR group.

Oline =PUSH= Both teams have very good young oline with 2 probowlers and young talent on their way too the probowl. I like Evans but Warton still doesn't get half the credit he deserves.

Dline = Saints = too many unknowns on the Panthers not many on the Saints.

LB = Panthers = Vilma needs too call Beason and say sorry for the misstake made by voters who put him over Beason. Try to do it before Brees and Bush gets punish for this injustice. Plus we have TDavis who is better then anybody they have so nuff said.

CB = Panthers = Porter and Greer are not better then Gamble and Marshall again 8th ranked def. 7th vs the pass against 20th somthing.

Safety = Saints = We are young but they have DSharper nuff said.

Special Team =Panthers = It better be us again we have spent all FA money in this spot.

again JMO.

[Mr ocho nueve]

I agree

[Guild]

TE and FB could easily change depending on what happens this season. Otherwise pretty much agreed.

[Dpantherman]

I have a problem with your use of "unknown". if its truly unknown, then how can you declare one better than the other? thats just like Jamie Duke--because he doesn't know who Matt Moore is the Panthers are screwed. im not trying to be cynical, but once again, until I see these guys play, I can't judge one way or the other

[bleys]

I think in the "unknown" situations, you have to go with the "known", even if it's to be on the safe side.. a little different than Jamie Dukes who doesn't know poo for shat...

[Dpantherman]

I think in the "unknown" situations, you have to go with the "known", even if it's to be on the safe side.. a little different than Jamie Dukes who doesn't know poo for shat...

I can agree w/ that. I still have my reservations though.

[CatMan72]

Don't know if I agree with the o-line assessment, maybe from a pass blocking standpoint but not a run blocking standpoint.

[Baschski]

Our o-line is bar none when it comes to run blocking.

[Guild]

Our o-line is bar none when it comes to run blocking.

Dallas has a really good (as in comparable to ours maybe worse maybe better) run blocking OL as well.

[BF91]

Its not just you, but I have a problem with "nuff said". If what you've said is enough, don't say anymore. No need to announce it to everyone.

Overall though, I agree with your comparison on the whole. I'm tempted to say our O-Line is better than theirs, but I don't know if that's just my Panthers bias showing through or not.

[pantherclaw]

Just don't ask saints fans to be objective.

[Fiz]

sharper was only a positive for the first half of the year unless you give credit to poo like "leadership" and "veteran presence"

[Fiz]

also before all the butthurt saints fans start mewling about porter and greer, keep in mind neither one can stay healthy and it doesn't mean poo if they can only play 8 games a year.

[Dpantherman]

also before all the butthurt saints fans start mewling about porter and greer, keep in mind neither one can stay healthy and it doesn't mean poo if they can only play 8 games a year.

you're back!