Question for our Eagle fans

[Mr. Scot]

How much of the Eagle fanbase has thrown out the "we should have kept Garcia over McNabb" argument this season?

What percentage would you estimate currently subscribe to that idea?

[magicman_buc]

I bet Garcia knows the overtime rules.

[Johnny Rockets]

None that I know of. But we do have our share of idiots.

It really hasn't been brought up much that I know of and I listen to Philly sports radio quite a bit but c0r and JGigs would probably know better. It never even crossed my mind honestly. I appreciated what Garcia did for us but never viewed him as starter material. McNabb pisses me off at times but I will always be a fan of his.

[Epistaxis]

My PhillyPhan buddy is WAY more down on Reid than he is on McNabb.

[Johnny Rockets]

My PhillyPhan buddy is WAY more down on Reid than he is on McNabb.

same here......bad thing is that I think it will be Reid that stays and Mcnabb that goes. I think they would still owe Andy something like 11 million if they fire him and the Eagles are to cheap to do that and then pay a new coach. Maybe they will prove me wrong.....

[Epistaxis]

But the next question is.....who would you want to replace him?

Despite his failings to win the "big game", he is a very successful coach.

And if you unload McNabb....same question.

The grass isn't always greener.

[Johnny Rockets]

But the next question is.....who would you want to replace him?

Despite his failings to win the "big game", he is a very successful coach.

And if you unload McNabb....same question.

The grass isn't always greener.

Personally, I would love to see Spagnola from the Giants come back to Philly. I also always hoped Jim Harbaugh would get promoted to the job when Reid left but Baltimore signed him away. I also have always been a Gruden fan and think he would be a great fit for the team and something tells me he would love to come back to Philly. No way it will happen because he would butt heads with the Eagles president too much.

Reid has been a successful coach and I appreciate what he has done for the team. It has been 10 years and his bone headed game time decisions, refusal to run the ball, or admit that the lack of a #1 receiver has been an issue that needed to be addressed has taken it's toll on me. Bottom line, when the game is on the line the last thing I want is him making the decisions. I know the grass isn't always greener but I am at the point where I really want to find out.

[frash.exe]

Reid has been a successful coach and I appreciate what he has done for the team. It has been 10 years and his bone headed game time decisions, refusal to run the ball, or admit that the lack of a #1 receiver has been an issue that needed to be addressed has taken it's toll on me. Bottom line, when the game is on the line the last thing I want is him making the decisions. I know the grass isn't always greener but I am at the point where I really want to find out.

And worst part is the one year you did have a no.1 reciever (Owens), you guys made it to the Superbowl. But he left a sour taste in the organization's mouth.