Would You Trade Draft Capital for a #1 WR???

[Navy_football]

11 hours ago, mav1234 said:

We absolutely need defense. I'm not saying don't go offense if the top player on our board when we draft is TMac, but our overall strategy must be to rebuild the D. Look at how Washington was able to rebuild in a single year... Now we need to.

Washington definitely improved their defense via FA. Mostly our guys. They just use them correctly. 

But they already had weapons and a great RB. They've just been in HC and QB purgatory since RG3.

[mav1234]

12 minutes ago, Navy_football said:

Washington definitely improved their defense via FA. Mostly our guys. They just use them correctly. 

But they already had weapons and a great RB. They've just been in HC and QB purgatory since RG3.

I miss Luvu, haha.  Chinn too, but really we hadn't used him well since his rookie year.

[Gapanthersfan]

The goal is to win football games. Lacking a true #1 receiver is not why this team lost, and it’s not even close. Defense still does win championships 

[unicar15]

Perfect offseason.

Trade down: Get Emeka Egbuka and additional 2nd for our 1st.

Trade current second for AJ Brown. 
 

That takes our WR corp from arguably worst in the league to possibly a top 10 unit with two moves. 
 

2nd Round: Jack Sawyer

IDC after that. If we have Egbuka, Sawyer, AJ Brown after day 1-2 I’m happy. 
 

FA: Austin Eckler, Dre Greenlaw, Hasson Reddick

These are likely low(er) cost FA with high upside. Kind of medium risk, high reward possibilities. This is also assuming Derrick Brown and Shaq can come back healthy. Which..if they can’t the defense is terrible anyway. 

[DaveThePanther2008]

On 1/13/2025 at 6:45 AM, Shocker said:

No way to validate this idea which makes it someone’s guess more than likely.   I said Garrett Wilson and 42 for 8.  Have to be sure he will sign here cuz he wants to be paid soon

I could almost bite on this one. They say the Edge is a deep class and 42 would most likely give us a good edge player. At 57 we take BPA defensive player. However, I seriously doubt NYJ would bite unless Wilson was going to hold out and demand a trade. 

[tukafan21]

16 hours ago, unicar15 said:

Perfect offseason.

Trade down: Get Emeka Egbuka and additional 2nd for our 1st.

Trade current second for AJ Brown. 
 

That takes our WR corp from arguably worst in the league to possibly a top 10 unit with two moves. 
 

2nd Round: Jack Sawyer

IDC after that. If we have Egbuka, Sawyer, AJ Brown after day 1-2 I’m happy. 
 

FA: Austin Eckler, Dre Greenlaw, Hasson Reddick

These are likely low(er) cost FA with high upside. Kind of medium risk, high reward possibilities. This is also assuming Derrick Brown and Shaq can come back healthy. Which..if they can’t the defense is terrible anyway. 

In no world would the Eagles give us Brown for our 2nd when there 100% would be teams out there who would give them their 1st for him.

He turns 28 soon and just signed an extension through his prime, someone like the Chargers would absolutely give them their 1st this year for him.  And even if not that, I could see the Patriots giving them their 2nd which would be well before ours, or a whole bunch of other teams who need WR help, that Rams 2nd is going to be late.

Edited 15 hours ago by tukafan21

[Donald LaFell]

The team is still so bad they just need to keep hitting on the draft while they recover from the Bryce trade and all the coaching failures. As long as we hit it will be ok. 
 

The front 7 needs bodies period. 

[CRA]

the OP has names like Kennan Allen, Chris Godwin, etc. in it.  I don't not consider those dudes to be true #1s in the year 2025.   I don't want to invest draft stock into old WRs who presently aren't even #1s.  That doesn't project out to be an answer for us.  That's a rental. 

[SOJA]

It really just depends on the WR and the compensation. If we're talking a third rounder or later I'm much more likely to pull the trigger. If it's pick 8 overall it has to be a certified WR1 not a WR 1B or a WR 2. Teams just don't make those available, esp after the titans fuged up the AJ brown trade. 

[rayzor]

On 1/15/2025 at 6:10 AM, Gapanthersfan said:

The goal is to win football games. Lacking a true #1 receiver is not why this team lost, and it’s not even close. Defense still does win championships 

defense doesn't win you games. it helps you keep from losing games you should win, which is what happened here the last half of the season.

the first half of the season we never stood a chance either way.