Who here was NOT HAPPY we won yesterday....

[TheBigKat]

Mark me down as someone who saw yesterday's win as pointless

I prefer the competitive losses then the pointless wins. We are now outside the top 5 and while we are more than one player away from turning this team around sometimes that one player CAN turn the team around

2020 

#6 Herbert

#7 Brown

 

2021

#7 Sewell

#8 Horn

 

 

[Icege]

This is that horrifying moment when you get to find out whether or not you agree with TheBigKat

[frankw]

I mean getting bummed over a win and agonizing over draft position is ultimately fruitless anyways considering our draft history the last few years.

[*FreeFua*]

Meh

Again, this team needs to learn how to win especially considering we have our young QB already

I was very pro tanking the year I knew we were trading up for a QB because each win was costing us another asset.

I also want Luther Burden so fine by me

[mrcompletely11]

4 minutes ago, TheBigKat said:

Mark me down as someone who saw yesterday's win as pointless

I prefer the competitive losses then the pointless wins. We are now outside the top 5 and while we are more than one player away from turning this team around sometimes that one player CAN turn the team around

2020 

#6 Herbert

#7 Brown

 

2021

#7 Sewell

#8 Horn

 

 

I mean a win is a win and we basically have the same front office so there is no guarantee a higher pick results in a better player so Ill take the win.  However I am most certainly not buying this mantra of "this win is a culture builder" bullshit.  Feels like the same thing was said with the saints in 2022.  I dont think pro football works like that

[mrcompletely11]

4 minutes ago, *FreeFua* said:

Meh

Again, this team needs to learn how to win especially considering we have our young QB already

I was very pro tanking the year I knew we were trading up for a QB because each win was costing us another asset.

I also want Luther Burden so fine by me

The draft threads are going to be great debate as we only have 3 wrs on contract but our defense is fuging putrid.  Not sure what side we should be targeting honestly.  I can see the logic of either.

[Manna]

2022:

#6 Ickey

#7 Evan Neal

 

2023:

#1 Bryce Young

#2 CJ Stroud

 

we just have to make the right pick when we pick. 

 

 

[Jon Snow]

[travisura]

Wins are far from pointless when you're trying to build a culture. Draft picks are always a risk, so I'd rather the team learn how to close out games and win than lose out and get a slightly better pick. This roster has so many holes that we are guaranteed to find a player at a position of need wherever we end up picking.

Edited December 23, 2024 by travisura

[PappyMay]

9 minutes ago, Manna said:

2022:

#6 Ickey

#7 Evan Neal

 

2023:

#1 Bryce Young

#2 CJ Stroud

 

we just have to make the right pick when we pick. 

 

 

2022-Icky 6

Charles Cross-9 (pff grade is  83.3 this year , Icky is 72.2 for reference)

[CBDellinger]

The best player in the nfl was picked 10th overall by a team that had just gone 12-4.    
 

Evaluation is more important than draft position. 

[Khyber53]

I'd much rather regularly be picking at the back of the first round than at the first.

Every year that we get further from the number one pick in the draft is an improvement.

I'm not here for specific players, I'm here for the team.

[jb2288]

26 minutes ago, TheBigKat said:

Mark me down as someone who saw yesterday's win as pointless

I prefer the competitive losses then the pointless wins. We are now outside the top 5 and while we are more than one player away from turning this team around sometimes that one player CAN turn the team around

2020 

#6 Herbert

#7 Brown

 

2021

#7 Sewell

#8 Horn

 

 

It doesn’t matter. There’s no surefire top end prospects this draft. Whatever happens, happens 

[45catfan]

There's not THAT guy in this draft unless you re talking a bout a two way player in Travis Hunter.  This is looking to be a depth draft, not select your sure-fire future HOFer.  Nobody in the top 10 has me overly giddy this draft.